Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology ›› 2024, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (5): 44-51.DOI: 10.13304/j.nykjdb.2023.0432
• BIOTECHNOLOGY & LIFE SCIENCE • Previous Articles Next Articles
Zhaodi YANG1(), Fenggen GUO1(
), Shiyu WANG2, Zhengjie LIU1, Wenhong LONG2
Received:
2023-06-25
Accepted:
2023-08-24
Online:
2024-05-15
Published:
2024-05-14
Contact:
Fenggen GUO
杨招娣1(), 郭凤根1(
), 王仕玉2, 刘正杰1, 龙雯虹2
通讯作者:
郭凤根
作者简介:
杨招娣 E-mail:yangzhaodisina@qq.com;
基金资助:
CLC Number:
Zhaodi YANG, Fenggen GUO, Shiyu WANG, Zhengjie LIU, Wenhong LONG. Effect of Plant Growth Inhibitors on Agronomic Traits and Pre-harvest Sprouting Resistance of Quinoa[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, 26(5): 44-51.
杨招娣, 郭凤根, 王仕玉, 刘正杰, 龙雯虹. 植物生长抑制剂对藜麦农艺性状和穗发芽抗性的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2024, 26(5): 44-51.
时期 Stage | 处理 Treatment | 株高 Plant height | 株幅 Plant width | 茎粗 Stem diameter | 叶长 Leaf length | 叶宽 Leaf width | 主穗长 Main spike length | 穗粗 Spike diameter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
初花期 Early flowering stage | CK | 104.67±3.06 aA | 37.00±1.00 aA | 1.53±0.06 aA | 6.47±0.45 bcdB | 12.30±0.26 abA | 10.07±0.12 aA | 4.75±0.48 abA |
A1B1 | 85.67±0.58 bB | 22.17±1.04 cC | 0.83±0.21 dC | 7.23±0.15 aA | 7.53±0.31 cB | 10.17±0.29 aA | 3.72±0.38 cB | |
A2B1 | 43.00±1.00 dD | 22.83±1.04 cC | 0.97±0.05 cC | 7.23±0.06 aA | 7.40±0.10 cB | 6.15±0.23 bB | 1.45±0.14 eD |
Table 1 Agronomic traits of different treatments
时期 Stage | 处理 Treatment | 株高 Plant height | 株幅 Plant width | 茎粗 Stem diameter | 叶长 Leaf length | 叶宽 Leaf width | 主穗长 Main spike length | 穗粗 Spike diameter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
初花期 Early flowering stage | CK | 104.67±3.06 aA | 37.00±1.00 aA | 1.53±0.06 aA | 6.47±0.45 bcdB | 12.30±0.26 abA | 10.07±0.12 aA | 4.75±0.48 abA |
A1B1 | 85.67±0.58 bB | 22.17±1.04 cC | 0.83±0.21 dC | 7.23±0.15 aA | 7.53±0.31 cB | 10.17±0.29 aA | 3.72±0.38 cB | |
A2B1 | 43.00±1.00 dD | 22.83±1.04 cC | 0.97±0.05 cC | 7.23±0.06 aA | 7.40±0.10 cB | 6.15±0.23 bB | 1.45±0.14 eD |
时期 Stage | 处理 Treatment | 株高 Plant height | 株幅 Plant width | 茎粗 Stem diameter | 叶长 Leaf length | 叶宽 Leaf width | 主穗长 Main spike length | 穗粗 Spike diameter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
初花期 Early flowering stage | A3B1 | 52.00±1.00 cC | 27.03±0.95 bB | 1.26±0.05 bB | 7.23±0.15 aA | 7.83±0.25 cB | 5.63±0.12 bB | 2.48±0.07 dC |
A1B2 | 101.00±1.00 aA | 37.43±0.60 aA | 1.62±0.03 aA | 6.27±0.06 dB | 12.40±0.17 abA | 9.99±0.08 aA | 4.65±0.36 abA | |
A2B2 | 102.67±3.21 aA | 38.55±2.36 aA | 1.60±0.02 aA | 6.63±0.38 bcdAB | 12.53±0.32 aA | 9.77±0.32 aA | 4.98±0.06 aA | |
A3B2 | 100.67±3.06 aA | 36.00±2.18 aA | 1.59±0.02 aA | 6.37±0.38 cdB | 12.47±0.42 aA | 10.10±0.26 aA | 4.70±0.36 abA | |
A1B3 | 101.00±2.00 aA | 37.70±0.36 aA | 1.63±0.03 aA | 6.87±0.06 abAB | 11.94±0.09 bA | 9.43±0.55 aA | 4.37±0.28 abAB | |
A2B3 | 102.33±3.06 aA | 36.33±1.26 aA | 1.58±0.03 aA | 6.80±0.17 abcAB | 12.13±0.35 abA | 10.00±1.00 aA | 4.52±0.19 abAB | |
A3B3 | 104.00±1.00 aA | 38.17±1.04 aA | 1.62±0.04 aA | 6.50±0.17 bcdB | 12.16±0.13 abA | 10.00±0.50 aA | 4.33±0.59 bAB | |
盛花期 Full flowering stage | CK | 155.33±3.06 aA | 43.17± 1.53 bcAB | 1.67±0.06 bB | 10.10±0.46 aA | 5.03±0.06 dC | 33.00±1.00 aA | 4.97±0.14 bB |
A1B1 | 92.00±1.00 eE | 22.50±3.04 eD | 1.13±0.06 dD | 6.50±0.62 cC | 4.27±0.25 eD | 12.33±0.58 cC | 3.27±0.23 eD | |
A2B1 | 86.00±1.00 fF | 31.50± 3.50 dC | 1.13±0.06 dD | 6.40±0.66 cC | 5.90±0.35 bcB | 14.00±1.00 cC | 4.03±0.10 cC | |
A3B1 | 143.33±1.53 cC | 44.83±5.97 abcAB | 1.34±0.04 cC | 6.67±0.29 cC | 6.13±0.31 bAB | 31.00±2.65 aA | 4.25±0.25 cC | |
A1B2 | 148.00±1.00 bBC | 44.67± 1.15 abcAB | 1.73±0.06 bB | 6.47±0.21 cC | 5.63±0.15 cB | 33.00±3.00 aA | 3.55±0.23 dD | |
A2B2 | 122.00±2.65 dD | 46.67± 1.15 abAB | 2.07±0.06 aA | 6.41±0.39 cC | 6.50±0.20 aA | 21.00±1.00 bB | 3.55±0.23 dD | |
A3B2 | 122.67±2.89 dD | 49.33±2.02 aA | 1.64±0.05 bB | 8.00±0.26 bB | 5.90±0.10 bcB | 21.67±1.53 bB | 5.93±0.26 aA | |
A1B3 | 153.00±3.00 aAB | 41.17±0.76 cB | 1.67±0.02 bB | 9.45±0.05 aA | 5.02±0.16 dC | 33.00±3.00 aA | 4.20±0.09 cC | |
A2B3 | 154.67±2.52 aA | 40.00±0.50 cB | 1.66±0.06 bB | 10.03±0.15 aA | 5.06±0.13 dC | 33.67±3.21 aA | 4.99±0.04 bB | |
A3B3 | 154.33±1.15 aA | 40.47±0.55 cB | 1.65±0.05 bB | 9.97±0.21 aA | 5.03±0.16 dC | 34.00±1.73 aA | 4.96±0.04 bB | |
灌浆期 Filling stage | CK | 171.33±1.53 aA | 26.67± 0.58 bcAB | 2.30± 0.05 aA | 2.93± 0.21 cB | 2.27± 0.15 cB | 45.33± 0.58 aA | 6.45±0.05 bB |
A1B1 | 97.00±2.00 hH | 30.50± 1.32 abAB | 1.53± 0.03 fE | 5.90± 0.96 aA | 4.337± 1.06 aA | 16.67± 2.08 fE | 3.73±0.15 eD | |
A2B1 | 108.33±2.08 gG | 28.50± 3.46 abcAB | 1.50± 0.01 fE | 3.57± 0.47 bcB | 2.40± 0.61 bcB | 15.67± 2.08 fE | 4.23±0.06 cC | |
A3B1 | 165.00±1.00 bB | 29.67± 6.25 abcAB | 1.53± 0.02 fE | 3.97± 0.51 bcAB | 2.93± 0.57 bcB | 32.67± 2.52 fE | 4.23±0.06 dD | |
A1B2 | 158.00±1.00 cC | 35.83± 5.58 aA | 1.85± 0.05 deCD | 4.47± 0.42 abcAB | 2.53± 0.46 bcB | 36.00± 1.00 dC | 3.90±0.05 fE | |
A2B2 | 144.33±1.53 eE | 34.00± 7.57 abA | 2.17± 0.03 abAB | 3.97± 0.32 bcAB | 3.23± 0.21 bAB | 22.67± 1.15 cC | 3.50±0.05 aA | |
A3B2 | 133.67±2.31 fF | 33.17± 6.29 abA | 1.75± 0.05 eD | 4.83± 2.34 abAB | 2.67± 0.32 bcB | 23.67± 1.15 eD | 6.97±0.08 deD | |
A1B3 | 163.33±3.21 bB | 34.00± 1.80 abA | 1.94± 0.03 cdCD | 3.43± 0.15 bcB | 2.63± 0.06 bcB | 40.00± 1.00 eD | 3.82±0.03 bB | |
A2B3 | 151.33±3.21 dD | 34.50± 0.87 abA | 1.98± 0.11 cdBC | 3.70± 0.20 bcAB | 2.80± 0.20 bcB | 40.00± 1.00 bB | 6.43±0.06 bB | |
A3B3 | 156.33±0.58 cC | 22.00± 1.00 cB | 2.03± 0.23 bcBC | 4.10± 0.10 bcAB | 2.87± 0.06 bcB | 41.67± 1.53 bB | 6.47±0.09 bB |
Table 1 Agronomic traits of different treatments
时期 Stage | 处理 Treatment | 株高 Plant height | 株幅 Plant width | 茎粗 Stem diameter | 叶长 Leaf length | 叶宽 Leaf width | 主穗长 Main spike length | 穗粗 Spike diameter |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
初花期 Early flowering stage | A3B1 | 52.00±1.00 cC | 27.03±0.95 bB | 1.26±0.05 bB | 7.23±0.15 aA | 7.83±0.25 cB | 5.63±0.12 bB | 2.48±0.07 dC |
A1B2 | 101.00±1.00 aA | 37.43±0.60 aA | 1.62±0.03 aA | 6.27±0.06 dB | 12.40±0.17 abA | 9.99±0.08 aA | 4.65±0.36 abA | |
A2B2 | 102.67±3.21 aA | 38.55±2.36 aA | 1.60±0.02 aA | 6.63±0.38 bcdAB | 12.53±0.32 aA | 9.77±0.32 aA | 4.98±0.06 aA | |
A3B2 | 100.67±3.06 aA | 36.00±2.18 aA | 1.59±0.02 aA | 6.37±0.38 cdB | 12.47±0.42 aA | 10.10±0.26 aA | 4.70±0.36 abA | |
A1B3 | 101.00±2.00 aA | 37.70±0.36 aA | 1.63±0.03 aA | 6.87±0.06 abAB | 11.94±0.09 bA | 9.43±0.55 aA | 4.37±0.28 abAB | |
A2B3 | 102.33±3.06 aA | 36.33±1.26 aA | 1.58±0.03 aA | 6.80±0.17 abcAB | 12.13±0.35 abA | 10.00±1.00 aA | 4.52±0.19 abAB | |
A3B3 | 104.00±1.00 aA | 38.17±1.04 aA | 1.62±0.04 aA | 6.50±0.17 bcdB | 12.16±0.13 abA | 10.00±0.50 aA | 4.33±0.59 bAB | |
盛花期 Full flowering stage | CK | 155.33±3.06 aA | 43.17± 1.53 bcAB | 1.67±0.06 bB | 10.10±0.46 aA | 5.03±0.06 dC | 33.00±1.00 aA | 4.97±0.14 bB |
A1B1 | 92.00±1.00 eE | 22.50±3.04 eD | 1.13±0.06 dD | 6.50±0.62 cC | 4.27±0.25 eD | 12.33±0.58 cC | 3.27±0.23 eD | |
A2B1 | 86.00±1.00 fF | 31.50± 3.50 dC | 1.13±0.06 dD | 6.40±0.66 cC | 5.90±0.35 bcB | 14.00±1.00 cC | 4.03±0.10 cC | |
A3B1 | 143.33±1.53 cC | 44.83±5.97 abcAB | 1.34±0.04 cC | 6.67±0.29 cC | 6.13±0.31 bAB | 31.00±2.65 aA | 4.25±0.25 cC | |
A1B2 | 148.00±1.00 bBC | 44.67± 1.15 abcAB | 1.73±0.06 bB | 6.47±0.21 cC | 5.63±0.15 cB | 33.00±3.00 aA | 3.55±0.23 dD | |
A2B2 | 122.00±2.65 dD | 46.67± 1.15 abAB | 2.07±0.06 aA | 6.41±0.39 cC | 6.50±0.20 aA | 21.00±1.00 bB | 3.55±0.23 dD | |
A3B2 | 122.67±2.89 dD | 49.33±2.02 aA | 1.64±0.05 bB | 8.00±0.26 bB | 5.90±0.10 bcB | 21.67±1.53 bB | 5.93±0.26 aA | |
A1B3 | 153.00±3.00 aAB | 41.17±0.76 cB | 1.67±0.02 bB | 9.45±0.05 aA | 5.02±0.16 dC | 33.00±3.00 aA | 4.20±0.09 cC | |
A2B3 | 154.67±2.52 aA | 40.00±0.50 cB | 1.66±0.06 bB | 10.03±0.15 aA | 5.06±0.13 dC | 33.67±3.21 aA | 4.99±0.04 bB | |
A3B3 | 154.33±1.15 aA | 40.47±0.55 cB | 1.65±0.05 bB | 9.97±0.21 aA | 5.03±0.16 dC | 34.00±1.73 aA | 4.96±0.04 bB | |
灌浆期 Filling stage | CK | 171.33±1.53 aA | 26.67± 0.58 bcAB | 2.30± 0.05 aA | 2.93± 0.21 cB | 2.27± 0.15 cB | 45.33± 0.58 aA | 6.45±0.05 bB |
A1B1 | 97.00±2.00 hH | 30.50± 1.32 abAB | 1.53± 0.03 fE | 5.90± 0.96 aA | 4.337± 1.06 aA | 16.67± 2.08 fE | 3.73±0.15 eD | |
A2B1 | 108.33±2.08 gG | 28.50± 3.46 abcAB | 1.50± 0.01 fE | 3.57± 0.47 bcB | 2.40± 0.61 bcB | 15.67± 2.08 fE | 4.23±0.06 cC | |
A3B1 | 165.00±1.00 bB | 29.67± 6.25 abcAB | 1.53± 0.02 fE | 3.97± 0.51 bcAB | 2.93± 0.57 bcB | 32.67± 2.52 fE | 4.23±0.06 dD | |
A1B2 | 158.00±1.00 cC | 35.83± 5.58 aA | 1.85± 0.05 deCD | 4.47± 0.42 abcAB | 2.53± 0.46 bcB | 36.00± 1.00 dC | 3.90±0.05 fE | |
A2B2 | 144.33±1.53 eE | 34.00± 7.57 abA | 2.17± 0.03 abAB | 3.97± 0.32 bcAB | 3.23± 0.21 bAB | 22.67± 1.15 cC | 3.50±0.05 aA | |
A3B2 | 133.67±2.31 fF | 33.17± 6.29 abA | 1.75± 0.05 eD | 4.83± 2.34 abAB | 2.67± 0.32 bcB | 23.67± 1.15 eD | 6.97±0.08 deD | |
A1B3 | 163.33±3.21 bB | 34.00± 1.80 abA | 1.94± 0.03 cdCD | 3.43± 0.15 bcB | 2.63± 0.06 bcB | 40.00± 1.00 eD | 3.82±0.03 bB | |
A2B3 | 151.33±3.21 dD | 34.50± 0.87 abA | 1.98± 0.11 cdBC | 3.70± 0.20 bcAB | 2.80± 0.20 bcB | 40.00± 1.00 bB | 6.43±0.06 bB | |
A3B3 | 156.33±0.58 cC | 22.00± 1.00 cB | 2.03± 0.23 bcBC | 4.10± 0.10 bcAB | 2.87± 0.06 bcB | 41.67± 1.53 bB | 6.47±0.09 bB |
处理 Treatment | 单株粒重 Grain weight per plant/g | 千粒重 Thousand grain weight/g | 产量 Yield/(kg·hm-2) |
---|---|---|---|
CK | 24.08±0.48 dC | 7.43±0.08 aA | 174.04±3.48 dC |
A1B1 | 19.23±0.08 fE | 6.81±0.23 cdBCD | 138.98±0.58 fE |
A2B1 | 25.07±0.25 cC | 6.62±0.32 dCD | 181.16±1.83 cC |
A3B1 | 21.44±0.26 eD | 6.63±0.015 dCD | 179.65±2.94 eD |
A1B2 | 28.22±0.36 aA | 6.88±0.24 bcdABCD | 203.91±2.57 aA |
A2B2 | 26.65±0.26 bB | 6.68±0.34 dBCD | 192.60±1.89 bB |
A3B2 | 24.86±0.41 cC | 6.73±0.11 dBCD | 178.90±0.86 cC |
A1B3 | 26.75±0.48 bB | 7.28±0.01 abAB | 193.34±3.45 bB |
A2B3 | 21.15±0.29 eD | 6.53±0.08 dD | 152.83±2.09 eD |
A3B3 | 24.75±0.12 cdC | 7.17±0.11 abcABC | 154.97±1.86 cdC |
Table 2 Yield traits of different treatments
处理 Treatment | 单株粒重 Grain weight per plant/g | 千粒重 Thousand grain weight/g | 产量 Yield/(kg·hm-2) |
---|---|---|---|
CK | 24.08±0.48 dC | 7.43±0.08 aA | 174.04±3.48 dC |
A1B1 | 19.23±0.08 fE | 6.81±0.23 cdBCD | 138.98±0.58 fE |
A2B1 | 25.07±0.25 cC | 6.62±0.32 dCD | 181.16±1.83 cC |
A3B1 | 21.44±0.26 eD | 6.63±0.015 dCD | 179.65±2.94 eD |
A1B2 | 28.22±0.36 aA | 6.88±0.24 bcdABCD | 203.91±2.57 aA |
A2B2 | 26.65±0.26 bB | 6.68±0.34 dBCD | 192.60±1.89 bB |
A3B2 | 24.86±0.41 cC | 6.73±0.11 dBCD | 178.90±0.86 cC |
A1B3 | 26.75±0.48 bB | 7.28±0.01 abAB | 193.34±3.45 bB |
A2B3 | 21.15±0.29 eD | 6.53±0.08 dD | 152.83±2.09 eD |
A3B3 | 24.75±0.12 cdC | 7.17±0.11 abcABC | 154.97±1.86 cdC |
处理Treatment | 穗发芽率SR/% | 穗发芽指数 SI | 籽粒发芽率GR/% | 籽粒发芽指数 GI | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
12 h | 24 h | 36 h | 6 h | 12 h | 24 h | 36 h | |||
CK | 40.85± 1.34 aA | 59.76± 4.42 aA | 81.37± 4.00 aA | 0.61± 0.02 aA | 23.00± 0.82 aA | 74.33± 2.62 aA | 98.67±0.47 aA | 99.67± 0.47 aA | 0.74±0.01 aA |
A1B1 | 31.07± 0.23 bB | 39.98± 1.94 cdBC | 66.63± 2.30 bB | 0.46± 0.02 bB | 1.33± 0.47 bcBC | 56.00± 0.82 bB | 98.33±0.94 aA | 98.67± 0.47 abA | 0.64±0.00 bB |
A2B1 | 29.64± 0.28 bcBC | 42.96± 1.51 bcB | 62.53± 0.51 bcdB | 0.45±0.00 bBC | 0.00± 0.00 dD | 40.00± 1.41 cC | 96.33±0.47 aA | 97.00± 0.82 bA | 0.58±0.01 cC |
A3B1 | 24.45± 0.32 dD | 44.14± 0.66 bcB | 65.11± 2.20 bcB | 0.45± 0.01 bcBC | 0.67± 0.47 cdCD | 12.00± 0.82 efE | 97.00±2.17 aA | 98.00± 1.41 abA | 0.52±0.02 dD |
A1B2 | 12.59± 0.37 BefEF | 35.89± 1.31 deC | 53.36± 0.94 deBC | 0.34± 0.00 eE | 2.00± 0.00 bB | 11.00± 0.82 fE | 81.67±1.89 cC | 91.00± 1.41 cB | 0.46±0.01 fE |
A2B2 | 14.34± 0.41 eE | 36.16± 0.55 deC | 52.10± 0.87 deBC | 0.34± 0.00 eDE | 0.67± 0.47 cdCD | 10.00± 1.63 fE | 54.67±2.49 eE | 89.33± 1.25 cB | 0.39±0.01 hG |
A3B2 | 11.36± 0.23 fF | 34.78± 0.58 eC | 57.56± 0.31 bcdBC | 0.35± 0.00 eDE | 0.00± 0.00 dD | 10.33± 0.47 fE | 71.00±1.63 dD | 85.33± 0.47 dC | 0.42±0.01 gF |
A1B3 | 30.98± 0.48 bB | 44.28± 0.60 bcB | 54.49± 2.79 cdeBC | 0.43± 0.01 bcdBC | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 38.00± 1.63 cC | 95.00±2.16 aA | 96.67± 1.70 bA | 0.58±0.01 cC |
A2B3 | 7.88± 0.44 cC | 46.31± 0.26 bB | 44.24± 13.70 eC | 0.40± 0.04 dCD | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 14.33± 1.25 eE | 87.67±0.47 bB | 96.67± 2.36 bA | 0.50±0.01 eD |
A3B3 | 23.17± 2.24 dD | 44.22± 3.81 bcB | 54.85± 1.24 cdeBC | 0.41± 0.02 cdBC | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 22.00± 1.63 dD | 82.67±2.06 cC | 98.67± 0.47 abA | 0.51±0.00 deD |
Table 3 Spike germination of different treatments
处理Treatment | 穗发芽率SR/% | 穗发芽指数 SI | 籽粒发芽率GR/% | 籽粒发芽指数 GI | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
12 h | 24 h | 36 h | 6 h | 12 h | 24 h | 36 h | |||
CK | 40.85± 1.34 aA | 59.76± 4.42 aA | 81.37± 4.00 aA | 0.61± 0.02 aA | 23.00± 0.82 aA | 74.33± 2.62 aA | 98.67±0.47 aA | 99.67± 0.47 aA | 0.74±0.01 aA |
A1B1 | 31.07± 0.23 bB | 39.98± 1.94 cdBC | 66.63± 2.30 bB | 0.46± 0.02 bB | 1.33± 0.47 bcBC | 56.00± 0.82 bB | 98.33±0.94 aA | 98.67± 0.47 abA | 0.64±0.00 bB |
A2B1 | 29.64± 0.28 bcBC | 42.96± 1.51 bcB | 62.53± 0.51 bcdB | 0.45±0.00 bBC | 0.00± 0.00 dD | 40.00± 1.41 cC | 96.33±0.47 aA | 97.00± 0.82 bA | 0.58±0.01 cC |
A3B1 | 24.45± 0.32 dD | 44.14± 0.66 bcB | 65.11± 2.20 bcB | 0.45± 0.01 bcBC | 0.67± 0.47 cdCD | 12.00± 0.82 efE | 97.00±2.17 aA | 98.00± 1.41 abA | 0.52±0.02 dD |
A1B2 | 12.59± 0.37 BefEF | 35.89± 1.31 deC | 53.36± 0.94 deBC | 0.34± 0.00 eE | 2.00± 0.00 bB | 11.00± 0.82 fE | 81.67±1.89 cC | 91.00± 1.41 cB | 0.46±0.01 fE |
A2B2 | 14.34± 0.41 eE | 36.16± 0.55 deC | 52.10± 0.87 deBC | 0.34± 0.00 eDE | 0.67± 0.47 cdCD | 10.00± 1.63 fE | 54.67±2.49 eE | 89.33± 1.25 cB | 0.39±0.01 hG |
A3B2 | 11.36± 0.23 fF | 34.78± 0.58 eC | 57.56± 0.31 bcdBC | 0.35± 0.00 eDE | 0.00± 0.00 dD | 10.33± 0.47 fE | 71.00±1.63 dD | 85.33± 0.47 dC | 0.42±0.01 gF |
A1B3 | 30.98± 0.48 bB | 44.28± 0.60 bcB | 54.49± 2.79 cdeBC | 0.43± 0.01 bcdBC | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 38.00± 1.63 cC | 95.00±2.16 aA | 96.67± 1.70 bA | 0.58±0.01 cC |
A2B3 | 7.88± 0.44 cC | 46.31± 0.26 bB | 44.24± 13.70 eC | 0.40± 0.04 dCD | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 14.33± 1.25 eE | 87.67±0.47 bB | 96.67± 2.36 bA | 0.50±0.01 eD |
A3B3 | 23.17± 2.24 dD | 44.22± 3.81 bcB | 54.85± 1.24 cdeBC | 0.41± 0.02 cdBC | 1.00± 0.00 cBCD | 22.00± 1.63 dD | 82.67±2.06 cC | 98.67± 0.47 abA | 0.51±0.00 deD |
Fig. 1 Natural ear germination rate of different treatmentsNote:Different capital and lowercase letters indicate significant differences between different treatments at P<0.01 and P<0.05 levels, respectively.
处理 Treatment | 整穗发芽试验 Germination test of whole spike | 籽粒发芽试验 Germination test of grain | 田间穗发芽率 SR in field | 平均隶属函数值 Mean membership index | 排序 Ranking | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
穗发芽率SR | 穗发芽指数 SI | 籽粒发芽率GR | 籽粒发芽指数 GI | |||||||||
12 h | 24 h | 36 h | 6 h | 12 h | 24 h | 36 h | ||||||
CK | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1 |
A1B1 | 0.703 3 | 0.183 9 | 0.603 1 | 0.429 4 | 0.058 0 | 0.727 7 | 0.992 4 | 0.948 7 | 0.737 9 | 0.825 3 | 0.621 0 | 2 |
A2B1 | 0.660 1 | 0.289 1 | 0.492 7 | 0.398 9 | 0.000 0 | 0.490 1 | 0.947 0 | 0.884 6 | 0.605 9 | 0.687 5 | 0.545 6 | 3 |
A3B1 | 0.502 6 | 0.330 6 | 0.562 1 | 0.381 7 | 0.029 0 | 0.074 3 | 0.962 1 | 0.923 1 | 0.444 4 | 0.868 5 | 0.507 8 | 5 |
A1B2 | 0.142 9 | 0.039 3 | 0.245 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.087 0 | 0.059 4 | 0.613 6 | 0.653 8 | 0.306 1 | 0.154 8 | 0.230 3 | 8 |
A2B2 | 0.196 0 | 0.048 8 | 0.211 9 | 0.009 2 | 0.029 0 | 0.044 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.589 7 | 0.111 1 | 0.075 2 | 0.131 6 | 10 |
A3B2 | 0.105 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.358 7 | 0.022 2 | 0.000 0 | 0.049 5 | 0.371 2 | 0.435 9 | 0.184 5 | 0.000 0 | 0.152 8 | 9 |
A1B3 | 0.700 8 | 0.335 5 | 0.276 2 | 0.334 4 | 0.043 5 | 0.460 4 | 0.916 7 | 0.871 8 | 0.589 1 | 0.644 5 | 0.517 3 | 4 |
A2B3 | 0.000 0 | 0.407 4 | 0.000 0 | 0.198 8 | 0.043 5 | 0.108 9 | 0.750 0 | 0.871 8 | 0.394 1 | 0.496 0 | 0.327 1 | 7 |
A3B3 | 0.463 9 | 0.333 5 | 0.285 8 | 0.244 4 | 0.043 5 | 0.222 8 | 0.636 4 | 0.948 7 | 0.423 5 | 0.426 4 | 0.402 9 | 6 |
Table 4 Comprehensive evaluation and ranking of ear germination subordination function under different treatments
处理 Treatment | 整穗发芽试验 Germination test of whole spike | 籽粒发芽试验 Germination test of grain | 田间穗发芽率 SR in field | 平均隶属函数值 Mean membership index | 排序 Ranking | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
穗发芽率SR | 穗发芽指数 SI | 籽粒发芽率GR | 籽粒发芽指数 GI | |||||||||
12 h | 24 h | 36 h | 6 h | 12 h | 24 h | 36 h | ||||||
CK | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1.000 0 | 1 |
A1B1 | 0.703 3 | 0.183 9 | 0.603 1 | 0.429 4 | 0.058 0 | 0.727 7 | 0.992 4 | 0.948 7 | 0.737 9 | 0.825 3 | 0.621 0 | 2 |
A2B1 | 0.660 1 | 0.289 1 | 0.492 7 | 0.398 9 | 0.000 0 | 0.490 1 | 0.947 0 | 0.884 6 | 0.605 9 | 0.687 5 | 0.545 6 | 3 |
A3B1 | 0.502 6 | 0.330 6 | 0.562 1 | 0.381 7 | 0.029 0 | 0.074 3 | 0.962 1 | 0.923 1 | 0.444 4 | 0.868 5 | 0.507 8 | 5 |
A1B2 | 0.142 9 | 0.039 3 | 0.245 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.087 0 | 0.059 4 | 0.613 6 | 0.653 8 | 0.306 1 | 0.154 8 | 0.230 3 | 8 |
A2B2 | 0.196 0 | 0.048 8 | 0.211 9 | 0.009 2 | 0.029 0 | 0.044 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.589 7 | 0.111 1 | 0.075 2 | 0.131 6 | 10 |
A3B2 | 0.105 6 | 0.000 0 | 0.358 7 | 0.022 2 | 0.000 0 | 0.049 5 | 0.371 2 | 0.435 9 | 0.184 5 | 0.000 0 | 0.152 8 | 9 |
A1B3 | 0.700 8 | 0.335 5 | 0.276 2 | 0.334 4 | 0.043 5 | 0.460 4 | 0.916 7 | 0.871 8 | 0.589 1 | 0.644 5 | 0.517 3 | 4 |
A2B3 | 0.000 0 | 0.407 4 | 0.000 0 | 0.198 8 | 0.043 5 | 0.108 9 | 0.750 0 | 0.871 8 | 0.394 1 | 0.496 0 | 0.327 1 | 7 |
A3B3 | 0.463 9 | 0.333 5 | 0.285 8 | 0.244 4 | 0.043 5 | 0.222 8 | 0.636 4 | 0.948 7 | 0.423 5 | 0.426 4 | 0.402 9 | 6 |
1 | ANTONIO V G, MARGARITA M, JUDITH V. Nutrition facts and functional potential of quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa willd.), an ancient Andean grain: a review [J]. J. Sci. Food Agric., 2010, 90(15): 2541-2547. |
2 | JACOBSEN S E, MUJICA A, JENSEN C R. The resistance of quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa Willd.) to adverse abiotic factors [J]. Food Rev. Int., 2003, 19(1-2): 99-109. |
3 | CARRASCO R R, ESPINOZA C, JACOBSEN S E. Nutritional value and use of the and an crops quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa) and kaniwa (Chenopodium pallidicaule) [J]. Food Rev. Int., 2003, 19(1-2): 179-189. |
4 | GRAF B L, ROJAS-SILVA P, ROJO L E, et al.. Innovations in health value and functional food development of quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa Willd.) [J]. Comprehensive Rev. Food Sci. Food Safety, 2015, 14(4): 431-445. |
5 | DAKHILI S, ABDOLALIZADEH L, HOSSEINI S M, et al.. Quinoa protein: composition, structure and functional properties [J]. Food Chem., 2019, 299(30): 1-43. |
6 | 王震, 李金秀, 张彬, 等. 不同生态区小麦品种的穗发芽抗性评价[J]. 应用生态学报, 2020, 31(12): 4161-4170. |
WANG Z, LI J X, ZHANG B, et al.. Evaluation of pre-harvest sprouting resistance of wheat varieties from different ecological regions [J]. Chin. J. Appl. Ecol., 2020, 31(12): 4161-4170. | |
7 | 王熹, 陶龙兴, 谈惠娟, 等. 外源脱落酸和马来酰肼对杂交水稻F1穗上种子发芽的抑制效应[J]. 植物生理与分子生物学学报, 2005, 31(4): 396-402. |
WANG X, TAO L X, TAN H J, et al.. Inhibitory effects of exogenous abscisic acid and maleic hydrazide on panicle sprouting in hybrid rice F1 [J]. J. Plant Physiol. Mol. Biol., 2005, 31(4): 396-402. | |
8 | 张睿, 吴晓毅, 马宝伟, 等. 不同浓度脱落酸对雷公藤悬浮细胞萜类次生代谢产物累积的影响[J]. 世界中医药, 2018, 13(2): 264-270. |
ZHANG R, WU X Y, MA B W, et al.. Effects of different concentration of ABA on terpenoid in cell of radix folium seu flos Tripterygii wilfordii [J]. World Chin. Med., 2018, 13(2): 264-270. | |
9 | 马金龙. 三种植物生长调节剂对藜麦生长及产量形成的影响[D]. 长春: 吉林农业大学, 2019. |
MA J L. Effects of three plant growth regulators on growth and yield formation of quinoa [D]. Changchun: Jilin Agricultural University, 2019. | |
10 | 毛琪, 晏兴珠, 王仕玉, 等. 30份藜麦资源的穗发芽抗性评价[J]. 种子, 2021, 40(10): 62-66, 73, 82. |
MAO Q, YAN X Z, WANG S Y, et al.. Evaluation of panicle germination resiatance of 30 quinoa resources [J]. Seed, 2021, 40(10): 62-66, 73, 82. | |
11 | 朱冬梅, 李曼, 李东升. 长江中下游麦区小麦新品种穗发芽抗性及鉴定方法研究[J]. 核农学报, 2018, 32(4): 795-801. |
ZHU D M, LI M, LI D S. Evaluation and determination method of pre-harvest sprouting resistance of new wheat cultivars in middle and lower reaches of Yangtze river [J]. J. Nucl. Agric. Sci., 2018, 32(4): 795-801. | |
12 | 蒋正文, 岳宏伟, 陈娇. 基于隶属函数法的宁夏滴灌玉米灌溉制度研究[J] .江苏农业科学, 2023, 51(7): 190-196. |
13 | 江玲, 万建民. 植物激素ABA和GA调控种子休眠和萌发的研究进展[J]. 江苏农业学报, 2007, 23 (4): 360-365. |
JIANG L, WAN J M. Advances in seed dormancy and germination regulated by plant hormones ABA and GA [J]. Jiangsu J. Agric. Sci., 2007, 23(4): 360-365. | |
14 | 张雪, 杨洪坤, 郑亭, 等. 外源ABA对两粒色小麦品种穗发芽及品质的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 2020, 53(23): 4750-4763. |
ZHANG X, YANG H K, ZHENG T, et al.. Effects of exogenous ABA on pre-harvest sprouting resistance and quality of white and red wheat cultivars [J]. Chin. Agric. Sci., 2020, 53(23): 4750-4763. | |
15 | 袁士林, 廖永萍, 袁浩. 植物生长调节剂抑制小麦穗发芽技术初探[J]. 江苏农业科学, 2000, 28(3): 21-22, 38. |
16 | 胡晋, 卢凤龙. 多效唑抑制杂交水稻种子穗发芽初探[J].种子世界, 1989, 18(10): 16-17. |
17 | 金茜, 杨发荣, 魏玉明, 等. 外源植物生长调节剂作用下藜麦株高的响应性变化[J]. 甘肃农业科技, 2018, 56(6): 50-52. |
JIN Q, YANG F R, WEI Y M, et al.. Responsive changes of quinoa plant height under exogenous plant growth regulators [J]. Gansu Agric. Sci. Technol., 2018, 56(6): 50-52. | |
18 | 刘瑞芳, 贠超, 申为民. 不同浓度矮壮素对藜麦株高的影响[J]. 现代农业科技, 2015, 44 (23): 156-160. |
19 | 姚丹, 李雪莹, 韩笑, 等. 植物生长调节剂对藜麦形态指标及其产量构成因素的影响[J]. 吉林农业大学学报, 2021, 43(1): 33-40. |
YAO D, LI X Y, HAN X, et al.. Effects of plant growth regulators on morphological indexes and yield components of quinoa [J]. J. Jilin Agric. Univ., 2021, 43(1): 33-40. | |
20 | 董立盛. 矮壮素对藜麦生长和产量的影响[J]. 青海农林科技, 2023, 53(1): 105-108. |
DONG L S. Effect of CCC on growth and yield of Chenopodium quinoa willd [J]. J. Qinghai Agric. For. Sci. Technol., 2023, 53(1): 105-108. | |
21 | 贺笑, 庞春花, 张永清, 等. 多效唑和矮壮素浸种对藜麦幼苗生长的影响[J]. 河南农业科学, 2018, 47(1): 26-31. |
HE X, PANG C H, ZHANG Y Q, et al.. Effects of soaking seeds with paclobutrazol and chlorocholine chloride on the growth of quinoa seedlings [J]. J. Henan Agric. Sci., 2018, 47(1): 26-31. | |
22 | 金茜, 杨发荣, 黄杰, 等. 花期喷施外源ABA对藜麦生产性状以及籽实品质的影响[J]. 分子植物育种, 2022, 20(5): 1643-1650. |
JIN Q, YANG F R, HUANG J, et al.. Effects of exogenous ABA spraying at flowering stage on production characters and seed quality of quinoa [J]. Mol. Plant Breeding, 2022, 20(5): 1643-1650. | |
23 | 赵牧其尔, 王志军, 包健, 等. 利用隶属函数法分析和评价不同生育期和贮藏时间的饲用谷子品质[J]. 草业科学, 2023, 40(1): 200-207. |
ZHAO M Q E, WANG Z J, BAO J, et al.. Analysis and evaluation of forage millet quality under different fertility and storage times using the membership function method [J]. Pratac. Sci., 2023, 40(1): 200-207. |
[1] | Yang FENG, Fenggen GUO, Shiyu WANG, Zhengjie LIU, Wenhong LONG. Codon Bias and Evolution Analysis of CqGAI in Chenopodium quinoa [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, 26(4): 27-36. |
[2] | Ziwen KONG, Ruxia TIAN, Ruyi MIAO, Yanping LIANG. Analysis of Agronomic Traits and Genetic Diversity of 60 Screw Pepper Germplasm Resources [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, 26(3): 40-47. |
[3] | Yan JIN, Quanhao SONG, Jiajing SONG, Liang CHEN, Lishang ZHAO, Jie CHEN, Dong BAI, Tongquan ZHU. Comprehensive Evaluation of 69 Wheat Germplasm Resources [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, 26(2): 33-45. |
[4] | Yurong DENG, Lian HAN, Jinlong WANG, Xinghan WEI, Xudong WANG, Ying ZHAO, Xiaohong WEI, Chaozhou LI. Identification of SOD Family Genes in Chenopodium quinoa and Their Response to Mixed Saline-alkali Stress [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2024, 26(1): 28-39. |
[5] | Pengfei LIU, Xiaoshuang LU, Dilimurat Reheman, Tangnur Slay, Yanying QU, Quanjia CHEN, Xiaojuan DENG. Genetic Variation Analysis of Main Quality Traits and Agronomic Traits in Upland Cotton Seed [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2023, 25(8): 22-32. |
[6] | Shan HE, Wei HAN, Yuancheng ZHOU, Weili HAO, Zhixia LIU, Yafei LAN, Dongchen NA, Min CHAI, Yiling WANG. Main Agronomic Characters Analysis and High Quality Germplasm Selection of Introduced Fagopyrum esculentum Moench [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2023, 25(6): 22-31. |
[7] | Qiujing CHEN, Zhaodi YANG, Shiyu WANG, Fenggen GUO, Xiaoxue ZHAO, Fan CHEN, Yang FENG. Effects of Plant Growth Retarders on Lodging Resistance and Yield of Quinoa [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2023, 25(11): 42-48. |
[8] | Ding DING, Lingjie ZHENG, Hongbao WANG, Lijin ZHENG, Yanchao GUO. Agronomic Traits and Effective Components of Different Tea Chrysanthemum Varieties in Coastal Area [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2023, 25(10): 45-53. |
[9] | Hongliang CUI, Xiaoxiao SONG, Qing YAO, Wangang AN, Bao XING, Peiyou QIN. Physiological Responses of Different Quinoa Varieties to Salt Stress and Evaluation of Salt Tolerance in Yili Valley [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(5): 32-45. |
[10] | Guanglei CHENG, Jun QIU, Xiaoguang WANG, Tianjun XU, Chuanyong CHEN, Chunyuan ZHANG, Qianqian XIA, Yuanqi WU, Jiuran ZHAO, Ronghuan WANG. Changes of Agronomic Traits, Biomass Yield and Quality of National Silage Maize Combinations (Varieties) [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(4): 30-37. |
[11] | Tianming QI, Zhijian LI, Peiyou QIN, Guixing REN, Bangwei ZHOU. Research and Application Prospect of Quinoa Cultivation Technology [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 157-165. |
[12] | TIAN Gang, LIU Xin, WANG Yuwen, LIU Yongzhong, LI Huixia, CHENG Kai, WANG Zhenhua, LIU Hong. Effects of Shading Treatment on Millet Agronomic Traits, Millet Quality and Cooking Characteristics [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(11): 47-54. |
[13] | LI Jinglin, LIU Shaodong, ZHANG Siping, CHEN Jing, LIU Ruihua, SHEN Qian, LI Yang, MA Huijuan, ZHAO Xinhua, PANG Chaoyou. Identification of Drought Tolerance During Whole Growth Period in Cotton Germplasm Resources and Resistance Index Screening [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(10): 52-65. |
[14] | YANG Ruiping1, LIU Ruixiang1, MA Yingmei1*, Guo Zhanbin2, ZHANG Hongwu2, BAI Yu1, ZHAO Xinyu1. Evaluation of Different Chenopodium quinoa Resources and Effects of Osmotic Regulators on Their Drought Resistance [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(9): 52-60. |
[15] |
WANG Hui, YANG Yuan, SHI Jinbo.
Adaptability Evaluation of Different Common Buckwheat Varieties (Lines) in Northern Shanxi
[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(8): 33-40.
|
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||