Progress in Integrated Rice-crayfish Farming System

doi:10.13304/j.nykjdb.2020.1114

Abstract

Abstract:

Integrated rice （Oryzasativa）-crayfish （Procambarusclarkii） farming system is considered as comprehensive farming system for rice and fisheries cultivation at the same time. In the recent years， it has developed rapidly in China， especially in the middle-lower reaches of the Yangtze River Basin. This paper reviewed the theoretical research progress and industrial development of rice-shrimp co-cropping mode in the past decade. In the view of theoretical research progress， the influence of integrated rice-crayfish farming system on paddy field ecology was clarified from the characteristics of paddy field soil， water quality， biodiversity and greenhouse gas emission. And in view of technical research progress， the development of green production technology of integrated rice-crayfish farming system was contributing in stabilizing the sown area and reducing the input of chemical fertilizers and pesticides. At the same time， enhanced quality and output of paddy rice and crayfish had been observed. But for long term and large scaled development of rice-crayfish industry still needed to carry out industrial organization optimization and upgrading. Alongside， there were a small number of risky questions arise in the development of integrated rice-crayfish farming system， such as invasion risk， germplasm degradation，“only emphasizing crayfish， but neglecting rice” and so on. Such tricky questions restricted the sustainable development of integrated rice-crayfish farming system. In order to promote the research and wide application of integrated rice-crayfish farming system and cope such limitations， 3 suggestions were put forwarded， establishing agricultural analysis system and information database about paddy field， classifying the promotion areas of rice-crayfish； strengthening the research of basic theory and integrated technology mode and at the same time promoting the integration of research， implementation and production； strengthening policy support and technical services to ensure the economic benefits of business entities.

Key words: integrated rice-crayfish farming system, ecological protection, food security, progress

摘要：

水稻（Oryzasativa）-克氏原螯虾（Procambarusclarkii，以下称小龙虾）共作模式作为稻渔综合种养的重要模式，近些年在我国尤其是长江中下游地区发展迅速。综述了近10年来稻虾共作模式相关理论研究进展和产业发展情况。在理论研究方面，从稻田土壤、水质、生物多样性和温室气体排放等方面阐述了稻虾共作对稻田生态的影响；在技术研究方面，稻虾共作模式的推广有利于减少化肥、农药投入，可在稳定水稻播种面积的基础上达到虾稻同步增产、品质同步提升的效果，但稻虾产业的发展壮大还需进行产业结构优化和升级。与此同时，稻虾共作模式的发展还存在入侵风险、种质退化、“重虾轻稻”等问题，制约了稻虾共作模式的可持续发展。为推动稻虾共作模式研究和广泛应用，提出3点建议：建立稻田信息库和农情分析系统，对稻虾共作推广区域进行等级划分；推进产学研一体化，强化基础理论和集成技术模式研究；加强政策支持和技术服务，保障经营主体经济效益。

关键词: 稻虾共作, 生态保护, 粮食安全, 研究进展

CLC Number:

S344.9

Hui XU, Yangyang ZHAO, Dongyue SUN, Yuanyuan KE, Lele ZHANG, Xiang CHEN, Fengzhen WEI, Jincai LI. Progress in Integrated Rice-crayfish Farming System[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 160-168.

许辉, 赵阳阳, 孙东岳, 柯媛媛, 张乐乐, 陈翔, 魏凤珍, 李金才. 稻虾共作模式研究进展[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2022, 24(2): 160-168.

Figures/Tables 2

References 52

1	国家统计局.中国国家统计局数据库［EB/OL］. ［2021-02-23］. .
2	ZHENG J Z， WANG W G， DING Y M， et al.. Assessment of climate change impact on the water footprint in rice production： Historical simulation and future projections at two representative rice cropping sites of China ［J/OL］. Sci. Total Environ.， 2020，709：136190 ［2021-02-23］. .
3	CHEN C Q， GROENIGEN K J， YANG H Y， et al.. Global warming and shifts in cropping systems together reduce China's rice production ［J/OL］. Global Food Security， 2020，24：100359 ［2021-02-23］. .
4	ZHANG M， YAO Y L， TIAN Y H， et al.. Increasing yield and N use efficiency with organic fertilizer in Chinese intensive rice cropping systems ［J］. Field Crops Res.， 2018，227：102-109.
5	赵建设，杨巧云，谢凯权，等.“稻鸭共作”模式的生态效益及其在生态农场应用的经济效益分析［J］. 中国农业科技导报，2019，21（11）：149-156.
	ZHAO J S， YANG Q Y， XIE K Q， et al.. Analysis of ecological benefit of “rice-duck farming” model and its economic benefit in ecological farm ［J］. J. Agric. Sci. Technol.， 2019，21（11）：149-156.
6	WANG J X， SHAN Q， LIANG X M， et al.. Levels and human health risk assessments of heavy metals in fish tissue obtained from the agricultural heritage rice-fish-farming system in China ［J/OL］. J. Hazard. Mat.， 2020，386：121627 ［2021-02-23］. .
7	中国稻渔综合种养产业发展报告（2020）［J］. 中国水产，2020（10）：12-19.
8	佀国涵，彭成林，徐祥玉，等.稻虾共作模式对涝渍稻田土壤理化性状的影响［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2017，25（1）：61-68.
	SI G H， PENG C L， XU X Y， et al.. Effect of integrated rice-crayfish farming system on soil physico-chemical properties in waterlogged paddy soils ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2017，25（1）：61-68.
9	BASHIR M A， LIU J， GENG Y C， et al.. Co-culture of rice and aquatic animals： an integrated system to achieve production and environmental sustainability ［J/OL］. J. Cleaner Prod.， 2020，249：119310 ［2021-02-23］. .
10	李嘉尧，常东，李柏年，等.不同稻田综合种养模式的成本效益分析［J］. 水产学报， 2014， 38（9）：1431-1438.
	LI J Y， CHANG D， LI B N， et al.. Benefit-cost analysis of different rice-based production systems ［J］. J. Fish. Chin.， 2014，38（9）：1431-1438.
11	张家宏，王桂良，黄维勤，等.江苏里下河地区稻田生态种养创新模式及关键技术［J］. 湖南农业科学，2017（3）：77-80.
	ZHANG J H， WANG G L， HUANG W Q， et al.. Innovative model and key techniques of ecological planting and breeding in paddy field in Jiangsu Lixiahe area ［J］. Hunan Agric. Sci.， 2017（3）：77-80.
12	曹凑贵，江洋，汪金平，等.稻虾共作模式的“双刃性”及可持续发展策略［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2017，25（9）：1245-1253.
	CAO C G， JIANG Y， WANG J P， et al.. “Dual character” of rice-crayfish culture and strategies for its sustainable development ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2017，25（9）：1245-1253.
13	2020中国小龙虾产业发展报告［J］. 中国水产，2020（7）：8-17.
14	稻渔综合种养技术规范（通则）［J］. 中国水产，2018（5）：81-83.
15	彭成林，袁家富，贾平安，等.长期稻虾共作模式对不同施氮量下直播水稻产量和氮肥利用效率的影响［J］. 河南农业科学，2020，49（4）：15-21.
	PENG C L， YUAN J F， JIA P A， et al.. Effects of long-term integrated rice-crayfish model on yield and nitrogen use efficiency of direct-seeding rice under different nitrogen application rates ［J］. J. Henan Agric. Sci.， 2020，49（4）：15-21.
16	吴本丽，陈贵生，赵慧敏，等.巢湖地区稻虾共作模式对稻田土壤肥力的影响［J］. 安徽农业大学学报，2018，45（1）：96-100.
	WU B L， CHEN G S， ZHAO H M， et al.. Effects of the integrated rice-crayfish mode on soil fertility in Chaohu lake region ［J］. J. Anhui Agric.Univ.， 2018，45（1）： 96-100.
17	SI G H， PENG C L， YUAN J F， et al.. Changes in soil microbial community composition and organic carbon fractions in an integrated rice-crayfish farming system in subtropical China ［J/OL］. Sci. Rep.， 2017，7（1）：2856 ［2021-02-23］. .
18	佀国涵，彭成林，徐祥玉，等.稻—虾共作模式对涝渍稻田土壤微生物群落多样性及土壤肥力的影响［J］. 土壤，2016，48（3）：503-509.
	SI G H， PENG C L， XU X Y， et al.. Effects of rice-crayfish integrated mode on soil microbial functional diversity and fertility in waterlogged paddy field ［J］. Soils， 2016，48（3）：503-509.
19	王蓉，朱杰，金涛，等.稻虾共作模式下稻田土壤氨氧化微生物丰度和群落结构的特征［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2019，25（11）：1887-1899.
	WANG R， ZHU J， JIN T， et al.. Characteristics of ammonia oxidation microbial abundance and community structure in paddy soils of rice-crayfish symbiosis farming system ［J］. J. Plant Nutr. Fertil.， 2019，25（11）：1887-1899.
20	徐祥玉，张敏敏，彭成林，等.稻草还田下非稻季持续淹水对稻季CH₄和CO₂排放的影响［J］. 农业资源与环境学报，2017，34（2）：145-152.
	XU X Y， ZHANG M M， PENG C L， et al.. Effects of continuous flooding in no-rice growing season on CH₄ and CO₂ emissions of rice growing season with straw returning ［J］. J. Agric. Resour. Environ.， 2017， 34（2）：145-152.
21	李文博，刘少君，叶新新，等.稻虾共作对水稻氮素累积及稻米品质的影响［J］. 生态与农村环境学报， 2021，37（5）：661-667.
	LI W B， LIU S J， YE X X， et al.. Effects of the integrated rice-crayfish farming on nitrogen accumulation and quality of rice ［J］. J. Ecol. Rural Environ.， 2021，37（5）：661-667.
22	夏天，方鹤楠，纪文文，等.稻虾共作快速发展背景下潜江耕地时空变化特征分析［J］. 长江流域资源与环境，2020，29（12）：2709-2718.
	XIA T， FANG H N， JI W W， et al.. Spatiotemporal characteristics of cropland in Qianjiang city under the development of rice-crayfish integrated ［J］. Resour. Environ.Yangtze Basin， 2020，29（12）：2709-2718.
23	陈欣，唐建军.农业系统中生物多样性利用的研究现状与未来思考［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2013，21（1）：54-60.
	CHEN X， TANG J J. Utilization of biodiversity in agriculture： today and tomorrow ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2013， 21（1）：54-60.
24	刘全科，周普国，朱文达，等.稻虾共作模式对稻田杂草的控制效果及其经济效益［J］. 湖北农业科学，2017，56（10）：1859-1862.
	LIU Q K， ZHOU P G， ZHU W D， et al.. Weed control efficacy and economic benefits of rice-lobster farming in paddy rice fields ［J］. Hubei Agric. Sci.， 2017，56（10）：1859-1863.
25	肖求清.稻虾共作对稻田生物多样性的影响［D］. 武汉：华中农业大学，2017.
	XIAO Q Q. Effects of rice-crayfish farming on biodiverity of paddy field ［D］. Wuhan： Huazhong Agricultural University， 2017.
26	徐大兵，贾平安，彭成林，等.稻虾共作模式下稻田杂草生长和群落多样性的调查［J］. 湖北农业科学，2015，54（22）：5599-5602.
	XU D B， JIA P A， PENG C L， et al.. Investigation of weed growth and community diversity in the rice-crayfish symbiosis farming ［J］. Hubei Agric. Sci.， 2015，54（22）：5599-5602.
27	袁伟玲，曹凑贵，汪金平，等.稻鱼共作生态系统浮游植物群落结构和生物多样性［J］. 生态学报，2010，30（1）：253-257.
	YUAN W L， CAO C G， WANG J P， et al.. The community structure and diversity of phytoplankton in rice-fish ecological system ［J］. Acta Ecol. Sin.， 2010，30（1）：253-257.
28	王强盛.稻田种养结合循环农业温室气体排放的调控与机制［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2018，26（5）：633-642.
	WANG Q S. Regulation and mechanism of greenhouse gas emissions of circular agriculture ecosystem of planting and breeding in paddy ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2018， 26（5）：633-642.
29	徐祥玉，张敏敏，彭成林，等.稻虾共作对秸秆还田后稻田温室气体排放的影响［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2017，25（11）：1591-1603.
	XU X Y， ZHANG M M， PENG C L， et al.. Effect of rice-crayfish co-culture on greenhouse gases emission in straw-puddled paddy fields ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2017，25（11）：1591-1603.
30	孙自川.稻虾共作下秸秆还田和投食对温室气体排放的影响［D］. 武汉：华中农业大学，2018.
	SUN Z C. Effects of straw returning and feeding on greenhouse gas emissions in rice-crayfish co-culture ecosystem ［D］. Wuhan： Huazhong Agricultural University， 2018.
31	SUN Z C， GUO Y， LI C F， et al.. Effects of straw returning and feeding on greenhouse gas emissions from integrated rice-crayfish farming in Jianghan Plain， China ［J］. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. Int.， 2019，26（12）：11710-11718.
32	徐祥玉.三种中稻模式稻田温室气体排放及影响因子研究［D］. 武汉：华中农业大学， 2020.
	XU X Y. Studies on greenhouse gas emissions and influencing factors of three middle-season paddy fields ［D］. Wuhan： Huazhong Agricultural University， 2020.
33	WANG A， MA X Z， XU J， et al.. Methane and nitrous oxide emissions in rice-crab culture systems of northeast China ［J］. Aquac. Fish.， 2019，4（4）：134-141.
34	GEDIK K， KONGCHUM M， DELAUNEA R D， et al.. Distribution of arsenic and other metals in crayfish tissues （Procambarusclarkii） under different production practices ［J］. Sci. Total Environ.， 2017，574：322-331.
35	佀国涵，袁家富，彭成林，等.稻虾共作模式下小龙虾养殖对水体环境的影响［J］. 江苏农业科学，2019，47（23）：299-303.
	SI G H， YUAN J F， PENG C L， et al.. Effect of crayfish aquaculture on water environment under integrated rice-crayfish system ［J］. Jiangsu Agric. Sci.， 2019，47（23）：299-303.
36	程建平，文玲梅，杨涛，等.增施微生物营养料对稻虾共作养殖水体水质及小龙虾产量的影响［J］. 湖北农业科学，2018，57（23）：121-123.
	CHENG J P， WEN L M， YANG T， et al.. Effects on the water quality and the production of crayfish by increased application of microbial nutrients in shrimp and rice farming ［J］. Hubei Agric. Sci.， 2018，57（23）：121-123.
37	易芙蓉，林玮诗，张鸣宇，等.稻虾共作对稻田水体环境的影响［J］. 作物研究，2019，33（5）：362-365，373.
	YI F R， LIN W S， ZHANG M Y， et al.. Effects of rice-shrimp co-cultivation on water environment in paddy fields ［J］. Crop Res.， 2019，33（5）：362-365，373.
38	邵乃麟，郭印，沈竑，等.枯草芽孢杆菌和空心菜对鳝虾稻共作池塘水质的影响［J］. 上海海洋大学学报， 2016， 25（3）：415-421.
	SHAO N L， GUO Y， SHEN H， et al.. The effects of Bacillussubtilis and IpomoeaaquaticaForsk on water quality in the pond for co-farming of rice-crayfish-finless eel ［J］. J. Shanghai Ocean Univ.， 2016， 25（3）：415-421.
39	HU L L， REN W Z， TANG J J， et al.. The productivity of traditional rice-fish co-culture can be increased without increasing nitrogen loss to the environment ［J］. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ.， 2013，177：28-34.
40	佀国涵，彭成林，袁家富，等.稻虾共作模式下秸秆还田对稻田氨挥发的影响［J］. 生态与农村环境学报， 2021，37（3）：360-368.
	SI G H， PENG C L， YUAN J F， et al.. Effect of rice straw returning to field on ammonia volatilization in paddy fields under the integrated rice-crayfish system ［J］. J. Ecol. Rural Environ.， 2021，37（3）：360-368.
41	石世杰，李纯杰，曹凑贵，等.稻虾共作模式下不同播期对水稻产量和品质的影响［J］. 华中农业大学学报，2020，39（2）：25-32.
	SHI S J， LI C J， CAO C G， et al.. Effects of different sowing date on yield and quality of high quality rice in rice-crayfish ecosystem ［J］. J. Huazhong Agric.Univ.， 2020，39（2）：25-32.
42	李丽华.西洞庭湖地区“稻虾共生”综合种养模式及其效益分析［J］. 作物研究，2018，32（S1）：46-47，52.
43	田玉聪，冯香诏，高珍珍，等.稻虾共作模式不同水稻播期土壤还原性物质含量及经济效益分析［J］. 湖北农业科学，2020，59（11）：57-61.
	TIAN Y C， FENG X Z， GAO Z Z， et al.. Analysis of soil reducing substance content and economic effect in different sowing times of integrated rice-crayfish system ［J］. Hubei Agric， Sci.， 2020，59（11）：57-61.
44	LIU M C， XIONG Y， YUAN Z， et al.. Standards of ecological compensation for traditional eco-agriculture： taking rice-fish system in Hani Terrace as an example ［J］. J. Mountain Sci.， 2014，11（4）：1049-1059.
45	钱炬炬，雷晓峰，李宏亮，等.益阳市南县“稻虾生态种养”——二三产业融合发展探析［J］. 天津农业科学，2018，24（3）：43-46.
	QIAN J J， LEI X F， LI H L， et al.. Analysis of the integration and development of the first， second， third industry of “rice and shrimp ecological breeding” in Nan County， Yiyang City ［J］. Tianjin Agric. Sci.， 2018，24（3）：43-46.
46	FALLER M， HARVEY G L， HENSHAW A J， et al.. River bank burrowing by invasive crayfish： spatial distribution， biophysical controls and biogeomorphic significance ［J］. Sci. Total Environ.， 2016，569：1190-1200.
47	CAI W， MA Z， YANG C， et al.. Using eDNA to detect the distribution and density of invasive crayfish in the Honghe-Hani rice terrace World Heritage site ［J/OL］. PLoS One， 2017，12（5）：e0177724 ［2021-02-23］. .
48	肖麒，章梦婷，吴翼，等.基于生态位模型的外来入侵种克氏原螯虾在中国的适生区预测［J］. 应用生态学报，2020，31（1）： 309-318.
	XIAO Q， ZHANG M T， WU Y， et al.. Prediction of potential distributions of the invasive species Procambarusclarkii in China based on ecological niche models ［J］. Chin. J. Appl. Ecol.， 2020，31（1）：309-318.
49	QIAN X Y， ZHU F. Hesperetin protects crayfish Procambarusclarkii against white spot syndrome virus infection ［J］. Fish Shellfish Immunol.， 2019，93：116-123.
50	LYU W W， ZHOU W Z， LU S B， et al.. Microplastic pollution in rice-fish co-culture system： a report of three farmland stations in Shanghai， China ［J］. Sci. Total Environ.， 2018，652：1209-1218.
51	王永春，李静，王秀东.新中国成立以来我国粮食生产变动规律研究及趋势展望［J］. 中国农业科技导报，2021，23（1）：1-11.
	WANG Y C， LI J， WANG X D. Change law and trend of grain production in China since the founding of the People's Republic of China ［J］. J. Agric. Sci. Technol.， 2021，23（1）：1-11.
52	胡亮亮，赵璐峰，唐建军，等.稻鱼共生系统的推广潜力分析——以中国南方10省为例［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2019，27（7）：981-993.
	HU L L， ZHAO L F， TANG J J， et al.. Extension potential of rice-fish co-culture system： a case study of 10 provinces in South China ［J］. Chin. J. Eco-Agric.， 2019，27（7）：981-993.

[1]	Jing ZHAN, Bin LIU, Ming CHEN. Influences and Prevention of Food Security in China Under Global Momentous Public Health Event [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 49-57.
[2]	WANG Xiaomei§, HE Wei§, YANG Xiaowei§, KONG Lingbo, LIN Qiao. Impact of COVID\\|19 Pandemic on Global Food Security and Countermeasures [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(5): 1-7.
[3]	HU Tingting, WANG Jiankang, DING Chengwei, GUO Rongliang, WU Yuling, XU Jiaan, WANG Youshuang, ZHAO Yipeng, HE Wanwan. Progress on Regulation Mechanism of Plant Seed Development [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(5): 27-34.
[4]	WEI Xun, §, SUN Kangtai§, LIU Hongbo, YAO Zhipeng, GE Yiqiang, DENG Xiaoming. Review on Management Experience and Scientific and Technological Innovation Progress of “Seven Major Crops Breeding” Project in “13th Five-Year Plan” [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(11): 1-6.
[5]	HUANG Jiazhang1, LU Shijun1, YAO Yuan2, WU Ming3, SUN Junmao1*. Visualization Analysis of Research Progress of International Nutrition-Sensitive Agriculture Based on Bibliometrics [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(9): 11-21.
[6]	LIN Hui, JIANG Zhongqun, MAO Jianhua*. Application and Research of Constructed Wetlands in Rural Wastewater Treatment [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(5): 129-136.
[7]	YANG Feifei, LI Shijuan*, LIU Shengping, LYU Chunyang, LIU Dazhong, XIAO Shunfu, LIU Hang. Research Progress on Hyperspectral Remote Sensing Monitoring of Crop Environmental Stress [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(4): 85-93.
[8]	ZHOU Miaoyi, REN Wen, ZHAO Bingbing, LI Hanshuai, LIU Ya*. Advances on the MAPK Cascade Pathway in Response to Abiotic Stress in Plant [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2020, 22(2): 22-29.
[9]	QIAO Yan1,2, SUN Jiaqing1,2, WEI Ruqian2, LIU Yue1,2,3*. Research Progress of GBS Technology in Plant [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2019, 21(8): 47-55.
[10]	SUN Yuzhu1, SUN Yongzhen2, WU Jingxue1, YAN Yan1*. Impact Analysis of Agricultural Technological Progress Mode on Grain Production Capacity——Based on the Provincial Panel Data of Three Major Grain Crops in 1999-2016 [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2019, 21(7): 1-9.
[11]	CHENG Bingxiao, ZHANG Dawei, YANG Liu, WEI Yue, MA Jingjun. Application Progress of Biological Insecticides in Bee Production [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2019, 21(7): 94-101.
[12]	MA Xiaohan1, GONG Zhixiang1, WANG Lin1, YANG Lijun2, HUANG Haitang2, XU Zicheng1*. Research Advance on β-aminobutyric Acidinduced to Stress Resistance In Tobacco [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2018, 20(5): 47-53.
[13]	ZHAO Ying, WEI Yue, YE Hongyan, MA Jingjun, CHENG Bingxiao. Research Progress on Residue Analysis of Organic Arsenic [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2018, 20(10): 115-122.
[14]	WEI Xun1§, GE Qun2§, HONG Dengfeng3, HU Han4, GE Yiqiang1. Research Progress of Modern Agricultural Technology in China During “12th Five Year” Plan Period [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2018, 20(1): 1-13.
[15]	CHANG Baiyang1, WANG Tongtong2, WANG Jianming1, WANG Min2. Research Progress on Application of Fumagillin in Agriculture Field [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2017, 19(9): 57-62.