Effects of Different Fertilizer and Water Treatments on Fruit Quality of 7 Table Grapes in Greenhouses

doi:10.13304/j.nykjdb.2024.0107

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to select the suitable irrigation amount and the best foliar fertilizer in Hotan facility grape cultivation， the table grapes of ‘Shine-Muscat’ ‘Hutai 8’ ‘Queen Nina’ ‘Summer Black’ ‘Xinyu’ ‘Heimeiren’ and ‘Crimson Seedless’ were used as materials， and 3 irrigation amounts were set including 4 500， 6 750， 9 000 m³·hm^-2 and 3 types of foliar fertilizer were selected including humic acid water soluble fertilizer， amino acid water soluble fertilizer， water. The fruit quality of 7 table grapes under different fertilizer and water treatments were determined. The results showed that the contents of total sugar and soluble solids in ‘Crimson Seedless’ ‘Queen Nina’ ‘Summer Black’ and ‘Xinyu’ grapes increased firstly and then decreased with the increase of irrigation amount. The fruit equatorial diameter and fruit weight of ‘Summer Black’ and ‘Heimeiren’ grapes increased with the increase of irrigation amount. The amino acid water-soluble fertilizer could not only promote the increase of fruit weight of ‘Hutai 8’ ‘Summer Black’ and ‘Xinyu’ grapes， but also promote the contents of total sugar and anthocyanin in ‘Hutai 8’ ‘Summer Black’ ‘Shine-Muscat’ and ‘Crimson Seedless’ grapes. The humic acid water-soluble fertilizer could significantly promote the increase of vitamin C content in ‘Shine-Muscat’ ‘Heimeiren’ and ‘Crimson Seedless’ grapes. The results of principal component analysis showed that ‘Shine-Muscat’ ‘Queen Nina’ and ‘Crimson Seedless’ grapes were suitable for irrigation amount of 9 000 m³·hm^-2 and application of humic acid water-soluble fertilizer. ‘Hutai 8’ grape was suitable for irrigation amount of 6 750 m³·hm^-2 and application of amino acid water-soluble fertilizer. The suitable irrigation amount and foliar fertilizer for ‘Summer Black’ ‘Heimeiren’ and ‘Xinyu’ grapes were 9 000 m³·hm^-2 and the amino acid water-soluble fertilizer. Above results provided some theoretical reference for fertilizer and water management of Hotan facility grapes.

Key words: grape varieties, fertilizer and water treatment, fruit quality, greenhouse

摘要：

为了探究和田设施葡萄栽培中适宜的灌水量和最佳叶面肥，以‘阳光玫瑰’‘户太8号’‘妮娜女皇’‘夏黑’‘新郁’‘黑美人’和‘克瑞森无核’葡萄为试验材料，分别设置4 500、6 750、9 000 m³·hm^-2共3个灌水量处理和喷施腐殖酸水溶肥、氨基酸水溶肥、清水3 个叶面肥处理，研究不同肥水处理对7 个鲜食葡萄果实品质的影响。结果表明，‘克瑞森无核’‘妮娜女皇’‘夏黑’‘新郁’葡萄的总糖、可溶性固形物含量随灌水量的增大呈先升高后降低趋势；‘夏黑’‘黑美人’葡萄的果实纵径、单果重随灌水量的增大而增大。氨基酸水溶肥可促进‘户太8号’‘夏黑’‘新郁’葡萄单果重增加，同时还可提高‘户太8号’‘夏黑’‘阳光玫瑰’‘克瑞森无核’葡萄的总糖、总花青素含量。腐殖酸水溶肥能显著提高‘阳光玫瑰’‘黑美人’‘克瑞森无核’葡萄果实的维生素C含量。主成分分析显示，‘阳光玫瑰’‘妮娜女皇’‘克瑞森无核’葡萄以灌水9 000 m³·hm^-2同时配施腐殖酸水溶肥为宜；‘户太8号’葡萄以灌水6 750 m³·hm^-2同时配施氨基酸水溶肥为宜；‘夏黑’‘黑美人’‘新郁’葡萄以灌水9 000 m³·hm^-2同时配施氨基酸水溶肥为宜。以上研究结果为和田设施葡萄肥水管理提供了理论参考。

关键词: 葡萄品种, 肥水处理, 果实品质, 设施温室

CLC Number:

S663.1

Guangyong SONG, Yawen GUO, Jing XUE, Keqing YANG, Xuede SU, Long ZHOU. Effects of Different Fertilizer and Water Treatments on Fruit Quality of 7 Table Grapes in Greenhouses[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2025, 27(7): 229-240.

宋光永, 郭雅文, 薛婧, 杨克箐, 苏学德, 周龙. 不同肥水处理对7个设施鲜食葡萄果实品质的影响[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(7): 229-240.

Figures/Tables 8

References 30

[1]	国家统计局农村社会经济调查司.中国农村统计年鉴-2023[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2023:1-179.
[2]	张小琴,王富霞,边凤霞,等.新疆和田地区葡萄轻简化栽培关键技术[J].中外葡萄与葡萄酒,2021(2):22-25.
	ZHANG X Q, WANG F X, BIAN F X, et al.. Key techniques of light and simplified cultivation of grapevine in Hotan region of Xinjiang [J]. Sino-Overseas Grapevine Wine, 2021(2):22-25.
[3]	阿丽米热·阿不都卡迪尔. 新疆和田县设施园艺产业帮扶效果评价及影响因素研究[D]. 石河子:石河子大学,2023.
	Alimire Abudukadier. Study on the effect evaluation and influencing factors of facility horticulture industry on industrial assistance in Hetian county, Xinjiang [D]. Shihezi: Shihezi University, 2023.
[4]	徐桂香,廉苇佳,刘萍,等.吐鲁番葡萄产业调研与分析[J].中外葡萄与葡萄酒,2020(3):70-74.
	XU G X, LIAN W J, LIU P, et al.. Investigation and analysis of the Turpan grape industry [J]. Sino-Overseas Grapevine Wine, 2020(3):70-74.
[5]	刘凤之,王海波,胡成志.我国主要果树产业现状及 “十四五” 发展对策[J].中国果树,2021(1):1-5.
	LIU F Z, WANG H B, HU C Z. Current situation of main fruit tree industry in China and it’s development countermeasure during the “14th five-year plan” period [J].China Fruits, 2021(1):1-5.
[6]	庞国成,刘凤之,王海波,等.不同灌水条件对设施葡萄果实品质的影响[J].中国果树,2019(3):57-61.
[7]	史祥宾,王孝娣,王宝亮,等.叶面肥添加微量元素对设施葡萄生长发育的影响[J].中国果树,2020(4):47-50.
[8]	王淑杰,刘勤保,于海业,等.设施葡萄调亏灌溉的理论与技术体系[J].农机化研究,2005,27(2):8-9.
	WANG S J, LIU Q B, YU H Y, et al.. The theory and technological system of regulated dilicit irrigation for grapery [J]. J. Agric. Mech. Res., 2005, 27(2):8-9.
[9]	王海波,史祥宾,王孝娣,等.设施葡萄植株不同生育阶段矿质营养需求特性研究[J].园艺学报,2020,47(11):2121-2131.
	WANG H B, SHI X B, WANG X D, et al.. Study on nutrient requirement characteristics of Vitis vinifera ‘87-1’ grapevine in protected culture [J]. Acta Hortic. Sin., 2020,47(11):2121-2131.
[10]	许健,张芮,黄彩霞,等.设施葡萄不同生育期水分胁迫对产量和水分利用效率的影响[J].中国农业大学学报,2019,24(4):43-51.
	XU J, ZHANG R, HUANG C X, et al.. Effect of water stress on the production and water consumption of grapes in facility [J]. J. China Agric. Univ., 2019,24(4):43-51.
[11]	车俊峰,郭春会,高疆生,等.不同叶面肥在3个葡萄品种上的应用[J].西北农业学报,2010,19(11):141-144.
	CHE J F, GUO C H, GAO J S, et al.. Application of different foliar fertilizer on three varieties of grapes [J]. Acta Agric. Bor-Occident. Sin., 2010,19(11):141-144.
[12]	赵阳,刘怀锋,牛媛,等.设施条件下灌水方案对弗雷无核葡萄产量及品质的影响[J].江苏农业科学,2019,47(13):167-170.
[13]	杨凡,田军仓,朱和,等.滴灌方式及灌溉定额对酿酒葡萄生长、产量及品质的影响[J].灌溉排水学报,2021,40(2):1-6.
	YANG F, TIAN J C, ZHU H, et al.. The effect of irrigation amount and drip irrigation methods on growth, yield and quality of wine grape [J]. J. Irrig. Drain., 2021,40(2):1-6.
[14]	曹建康,姜微波,赵玉梅.果蔬采后生理生化实验指导[M].北京:中国轻工业出版社,2007:21-67.
[15]	刘洪海,张晓丽,杜平,等.pH示差法测定烟73葡萄中花青素含量[J].中国调味品,2009,34(4):110-111, 117.
	LIU H H, ZHANG X L, DU P, et al.. Determination the anthocyanin content in Yan73 grape by pH-differential method [J]. China Condiment, 2009,34(4):110-111, 117.
[16]	PRABAKARAN G, VAITHIYANATHAN D, GANESAN M. Fuzzy decision support system for improving the crop productivity and efficient use of fertilizers [J]. Comput. Electron. Agric., 2018,150:88-97.
[17]	农业农村部.农业农村部关于落实党中央国务院2023年全面推进乡村振兴重点工作部署的实施意见[J]. 中国农技推广,2023,39(2):80-87.
[18]	牛小霞,马忠明,陈娟,等.灌溉量和滴灌方式对酿酒葡萄品质的影响及综合评价[J].节水灌溉,2023(8):136-142.
	NIU X X, MA Z M, CHEN J, et al.. Effects of different irrigation amount and drip irrigation modes on wine grape fruit quality and comprehensive evaluation [J]. Water Sav. Irrig., 2023(8):136-142.
[19]	王东,曹源倍,吉遥芳,等.不同滴灌量对红寺堡区酿酒葡萄生长和品质的影响[J].中国农业科技导报,2021,23(1):154-161.
	WANG D, CAO Y B, JI Y F, et al.. Effects of different drip irrigation on the growth and quality of wine grapes in Hongsibu district [J]. J. Agric. Sci. Technol., 2021,23(1):154-161.
[20]	张彩仙,杨苗,杨萍果,等.灌水量对鲜食葡萄生长及品质的影响[J].灌溉排水学报,2022,41(9):16-22.
	ZHANG C X, YANG M, YANG P G, et al.. Effects of irrigation amount on growth and fruit quality of table grape [J]. J.Irrig. Drain., 2022,41(9):16-22.
[21]	常宏达,吕德生,王振华,等.滴灌量和有机无机肥等氮配施对葡萄产量及品质的影响[J].干旱地区农业研究,2022,40(4):116-123.
	CHANG H D, LYU D S, WANG Z H, et al.. Effects of drip irrigation water amount and equal nitrogen applicating organic-inorganic fertilizer ratios on grape yield and quality [J]. Agric.Res. Arid Areas, 2022,40(4):116-123.
[22]	刘爱玲,何建军,王磊,等. 设施栽培‘峰后’葡萄营养元素和水分吸收规律研究[J]. 果树学报,2012,29(5):852-860.
	LIU A L, HE J J, WANG L, et al.. Study on absorption of nutrient elements and water of protectively cultivated ‘Fenghou’ grape [J]. J. Fruit Sci., 2012,29(5):852-860.
[23]	宋长年,周哲,邹典旭,等.叶面肥在葡萄生产中的应用进展[J].安徽农业科学,2022,50(19):11-15.
	SONG C N, ZHOU Z, ZOU D X, et al.. Application progress of foliar fertilizer in grape production [J]. J.Anhui Agric. Sci., 2022,50(19):11-15.
[24]	马彦飞,刘小会,颖强.三种新型叶面肥在葡萄上的应用初报[J].中外葡萄与葡萄酒,2015(3):28-31.
	MA Y F, LIU X H, YING Q. Application effects of three new foliar-fertilizers on grapevine [J]. Sino-Overseas Grapevine Wine, 2015(3):28-31.
[25]	王海波,王孝娣,姚秀业,等.氨基酸硒叶面肥在玫瑰香葡萄上的应用效果[J].中外葡萄与葡萄酒,2011(5):47-49.
[26]	曾成城,苏天明,苏利荣,等.减量化肥配施叶面肥对山核桃产量及品质的影响[J].中国土壤与肥料,2022(6):108-114.
	ZENG C C, SU T M, SU L R, et al.. Effects of reducing chemical fertilizer combined with foliar fertilization on the yield and quality of Carya cathayensis [J]. Soil Fert. Sci. China, 2022(6):108-114.
[27]	张晓荣.氨基酸系列叶面肥在温室葡萄上的应用效果分析[J].中外葡萄与葡萄酒,2017(4):84-85.
[28]	CANELLAS L P, PICCOLO A, DOBBSS L B, et al.. Chemical composition and bioactivity properties of size-fractions separated from a vermicompost humic acid [J]. Chemosphere, 2010,78(4):457-466.
[29]	El-GHAMRY A M, ABD K M, GHONEEM K M. Amino and humic acids promote growth, yield and disease resistance of Faba bean cultivated in clayey soil [J]. Aust. J. Basic Appl. Sci., 2009,3(2):731-739.
[30]	李延菊,张序,卢建声,等.喷施叶面肥对甜樱桃坐果率及果实品质的影响[J].中国果树,2013(5):34-36.

处理 Treatment	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）	叶面肥Foliar fertilizer
处理 Treatment	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）	清水Water/（L·hm^-2）	腐殖酸水溶肥Humic acid water soluble fertilizer /（L·hm^-2）	氨基酸水溶肥Amino acid water soluble fertilizer /（L·hm^-2）
A1B0	4 500	2 143	0	0
A1B1	4 500	0	2 143	0
A1B2	4 500	0	0	2 143
A2B0	6 750	2 143	0	0
A2B1	6 750	0	2 143	0
A2B2	6 750	0	0	2 143
A3B0	9 000	2 143	0	0
A3B1	9 000	0	2 143	0
A3B2	9 000	0	0	2 143

处理 Treatment	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）	叶面肥Foliar fertilizer
处理 Treatment	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）	清水Water/（L·hm^-2）	腐殖酸水溶肥Humic acid water soluble fertilizer /（L·hm^-2）	氨基酸水溶肥Amino acid water soluble fertilizer /（L·hm^-2）
A1B0	4 500	2 143	0	0
A1B1	4 500	0	2 143	0
A1B2	4 500	0	0	2 143
A2B0	6 750	2 143	0	0
A2B1	6 750	0	2 143	0
A2B2	6 750	0	0	2 143
A3B0	9 000	2 143	0	0
A3B1	9 000	0	2 143	0
A3B2	9 000	0	0	2 143

时期 Period	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）			灌水次数Irrigation frequency	灌水周期Irrigation cycle/d
时期 Period	A1	A2	A3	灌水次数Irrigation frequency	灌水周期Irrigation cycle/d
伤流期Bleeding period	225.00	375.00	525.00	1	—
萌芽期Budding stage	225.00	300.00	375.00	2	10
新梢生长期Shoot-growing stage	750.00	1 125.00	1 500.00	6	5
花期Blooming period	150.00	225.00	300.00	2	5
果实膨大期Fruit expanding stage	975.00	1 500.00	2 025.00	7	5
果实成熟期Fruit maturation period	806.25	1 162.50	1 518.75	8	5
落叶期Deciduous period	1 068.75	1 612.50	2 156.25	8	10
休眠期Dormant period	300.00	450.00	600.00	1	—
全生育期Whole growth period	4 500.00	6 750.00	9 000.00	35	—

时期 Period	灌水量Irrigation amount/（m³·hm^-2）			灌水次数Irrigation frequency	灌水周期Irrigation cycle/d
时期 Period	A1	A2	A3	灌水次数Irrigation frequency	灌水周期Irrigation cycle/d
伤流期Bleeding period	225.00	375.00	525.00	1	—
萌芽期Budding stage	225.00	300.00	375.00	2	10
新梢生长期Shoot-growing stage	750.00	1 125.00	1 500.00	6	5
花期Blooming period	150.00	225.00	300.00	2	5
果实膨大期Fruit expanding stage	975.00	1 500.00	2 025.00	7	5
果实成熟期Fruit maturation period	806.25	1 162.50	1 518.75	8	5
落叶期Deciduous period	1 068.75	1 612.50	2 156.25	8	10
休眠期Dormant period	300.00	450.00	600.00	1	—
全生育期Whole growth period	4 500.00	6 750.00	9 000.00	35	—

品种Variety	处理Treatment	果柄长Fruit stalk length/mm	果实纵径Fruit equatorial diameter/mm	果实横径Fruit transverse diameter/mm	去皮硬度Peeling hardness/（kg·cm^-2）	单果重Fruit weight/g
阳光玫瑰Shine-Muscat	A1B0	7.42±1.31 bc	17.22±0.59 f	15.89±0.66 c	2.19±0.46 a	3.05±0.38 e
	A1B1	7.03±0.80 c	20.84±1.18 b	18.15±0.76 b	1.43±0.17 bcd	4.71±0.52 b
	A1B2	7.30±0.75 bc	18.14±0.95 ef	16.58±1.76 c	1.14±0.09 de	3.78±0.32 c
	A2B0	8.39±0.99 a	19.54±0.97 bcd	17.85±0.81 b	1.58±0.24 bc	4.13±0.52 bc
	A2B1	8.47±1.13 a	20.36±1.43 bc	18.84±0.78 b	1.75±0.25 b	4.84±0.57 b
	A2B2	8.56±0.97 a	19.45±2.08 cde	18.64±1.81 b	1.77±0.47 b	4.76±1.39 b
	A3B0	5.84±1.09 d	18.58±1.94 de	18.06±1.82 b	1.09±0.11 e	4.27±1.04 bc
	A3B1	8.09±0.92 abc	22.31±1.16 a	20.59±1.00 a	1.43±0.25 bcd	6.20±0.80 a
	A3B2	7.59±1.06 abc	19.00±1.01 de	18.06±0.78 b	1.25±0.30 cde	4.47±0.36 bc
户太8号Hutai 8	A1B0	9.62±0.58 ab	18.24±1.15 cd	17.27±0.99 c	0.79±0.10 bc	3.81±0.47 cde
	A1B1	10.17±1.08 a	19.85±1.40 b	18.14±1.26 c	1.02±0.06 abc	4.48±0.90 c
	A1B2	9.59±0.78 ab	19.12±0.54 bc	18.08±0.91 c	1.00±0.15 abc	4.24±0.42 cd
	A2B0	10.24±1.23 a	17.26±1.22 d	17.15±0.48 c	1.04±0.20 abc	3.64±0.21 def
	A2B1	8.41±0.82 c	17.80±1.31 d	15.77±0.94 d	0.93±0.09 abc	3.17±0.57 ef
	A2B2	9.79±0.80 a	22.19±0.76 a	20.95±0.57 a	1.02±0.15 abc	6.17±0.43 a
	A3B0	8.70±1.06 bc	17.72±0.73 d	17.33±0.77 c	0.76±0.16 c	3.09±0.46 f
	A3B1	9.46±0.84 ab	19.75±1.61 b	17.29±1.85 c	1.09±0.11 a	4.07±0.87 cd
	A3B2	10.18±0.98 a	20.44±1.21 b	19.62±1.12 b	1.06±0.16 ab	5.27±0.80 b
妮娜女皇Queen Nina	A1B0	8.35±0.45 bc	25.47±1.40 ab	20.80±0.61 b	1.44±0.19 d	6.88±0.37 b
	A1B1	8.56±0.87 bc	25.67±1.00 ab	22.51±0.81 a	1.34±0.08 d	8.40±0.56 a
	A1B2	7.56±0.37 c	21.81±1.59 d	17.31±0.29 d	1.41±0.10 d	4.43±0.45 d
	A2B0	9.79±1.41 a	23.79±1.50 c	19.37±0.78 c	1.84±0.32 bc	5.76±0.79 c
	A2B1	7.92±1.14 bc	19.98±1.68 e	18.09±0.75 d	1.59±0.29 cd	4.25±0.51 d
	A2B2	8.46±0.93 bc	23.07±1.03 cd	19.03±0.85 c	2.07±0.29 b	5.44±0.60 c
	A3B0	7.94±0.65 bc	24.48±0.73 bc	21.00±0.52 b	1.52±0.09 d	6.96±0.30 b
	A3B1	7.83±0.44 c	25.76±1.63 ab	22.58±0.63 a	2.52±0.17 a	8.63±0.82 a
	A3B2	8.91±0.97 ab	26.19±1.91 a	22.58±1.33 a	1.47±0.09 d	8.80±1.47 a
夏黑Summer Black	A1B0	6.69±0.97 ab	12.01±0.30 bc	11.99±0.31 c	1.04±0.12 ab	1.18±0.05 b
	A1B1	5.20±1.15 c	11.52±0.27 c	11.97±0.54 c	1.11±0.10 ab	1.26±0.10 b
	A1B2	6.28±1.07 abc	12.44±0.36 bc	12.25±0.29 bc	1.09±0.14 ab	1.34±0.14 b
	A2B0	6.10±0.37 abc	13.03±0.55 b	13.21±0.51 ab	1.20±0.20 ab	1.37±0.22 b
	A2B1	7.18±1.09 a	11.93±0.64 bc	12.22±0.40 bc	1.24±0.28 ab	1.32±0.07 b
	A2B2	6.41±0.49 abc	12.56±1.60 bc	12.45±1.14 bc	0.98±0.13 b	1.52±0.48 b
	A3B0	5.69±0.37 bc	12.73±0.79 bc	13.14±0.70 ab	1.16±0.09 ab	1.60±0.15 ab
	A3B1	6.60±0.68 ab	12.90±0.43 b	13.55±0.58 a	1.30±0.17 a	1.45±0.19 b
	A3B2	7.40±1.01 a	14.66±1.43 a	14.19±1.08 a	1.17±0.23 ab	1.95±0.48 a
新郁Xinyu	A1B0	8.20±1.93 abc	26.25±1.32 c	21.26±0.61 d	2.72±0.31 b	7.28±0.52 e
	A1B1	8.97±0.56 ab	25.66±0.90 c	21.86±1.02 cd	2.46±0.35 bcd	8.11±0.52 cd
	A1B2	8.42±1.02 abc	19.53±2.70 d	16.63±1.25 f	2.44±0.25 bcd	3.34±0.93 g
	A2B0	9.36±1.03 a	28.51±0.64 b	22.05±0.63 cd	2.26±0.27 cd	7.40±0.62 de
	A2B1	7.59±0.83 c	25.62±2.10 c	19.45±1.46 e	2.20±0.32 d	6.30±1.30 f
	A2B2	8.74±0.73 ab	25.87±1.76 c	22.56±0.87 bc	1.61±0.13 e	8.64±0.77 c
	A3B0	8.89±0.69 ab	28.56±0.78 b	22.54±0.66 bc	2.64±0.19 b	8.70±0.47 bc
	A3B1	8.11±0.80 bc	30.26±1.96 ab	23.09±0.50 b	3.40±0.31 a	9.43±0.54 b
	A3B2	8.79±0.64 ab	30.70±0.99 a	25.65±0.76 a	2.58±0.24 bc	12.39±0.57 a
黑美人Heimeiren	A1B0	9.26±0.89 abc	30.05±2.19 cd	13.32±1.13 a	2.65±0.02 a	3.31±0.55 d
	A1B1	8.73±1.73 bc	27.21±0.85 d	10.78±0.36 b	2.51±0.28 a	2.47±0.25 e
	A1B2	8.49±0.90 bc	31.39±1.79 bc	13.45±1.35 a	2.87±0.10 a	3.96±0.53 bcd
	A2B0	8.82±1.34 abc	32.20±2.64 bc	13.42±1.10 a	2.44±0.23 a	3.57±0.75 cd
	A2B1	7.82±1.45 c	32.85±6.49 bc	12.82±0.69 a	2.69±0.17 a	3.60±1.05 cd
	A2B2	8.69±1.80 bc	34.31±2.39 b	14.03±1.05 a	2.72±0.17 a	4.19±0.57 bc
	A3B0	8.92±0.93 abc	32.05±2.21 bc	13.05±1.17 a	2.67±0.19 a	3.53±0.65 cd
	A3B1	9.82±0.80 ab	38.70±2.87 a	13.58±0.51 a	2.77±0.36 a	4.59±0.68 b
	A3B2	10.42±0.86 a	40.71±2.54 a	14.10±0.55 a	2.68±0.22 a	5.65±0.43 a
克瑞森无核Crimson Seedless	A1B0	5.45±0.73 cd	20.50±1.01 a	15.08±0.69 a	2.76±0.31 a	3.06±0.34 a
	A1B1	4.80±0.66 d	13.35±0.57 d	10.21±0.13 d	1.55±0.39 e	1.79±0.06 e
	A1B2	6.15±0.64 bc	18.66±1.01 b	13.86±0.57 b	2.71±0.10 a	2.38±0.25 c
	A2B0	6.24±1.15 abc	16.92±1.54 c	12.75±0.47 c	1.65±0.10 e	2.01±0.23 d
	A2B1	7.18±0.41 a	18.91±0.81 b	14.45±0.52 ab	2.12±0.32 cd	2.88±0.22 ab
	A2B2	6.32±0.54 abc	17.03±0.90 c	14.36±0.41 ab	2.15±0.29 c	2.49±0.16 c
	A3B0	6.63±0.59 ab	20.57±1.77 a	14.82±0.84 a	1.79±0.18 de	2.95±0.45 ab
	A3B1	6.01±0.79 bc	19.87±0.94 ab	15.11±0.52 a	2.59±0.25 ab	3.22±0.27 a
	A3B2	6.34±0.82 abc	19.65±0.66 ab	13.99±0.28 b	2.27±0.29 bc	2.63±0.13 bc