Research on International Comparison and Development Strategy of Competitiveness of China’s Oilseed Industry

doi:10.13304/j.nykjdb.2023.0763

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to further enhance the competitiveness of China’s oilseed industry and promote its high-quality development， the data of oilseed production， consumption and trade since 2000 were selected， and the competitiveness of China’s oilseed industry from the perspectives of absolute advantage， comparative advantage and enterprise competitiveness were systematically analyzed， the main reasons affecting the competitiveness of China’s oilseed industry were discussed by calculating the contribution rate of oilseed planting technology and the trade competitiveness index. The results showed that China’s oilseed industry was at a disadvantage in all the aspects of absolute advantage， comparative advantage and enterprise competitiveness， and the limiting factors were insufficient resource endowment， low contribution of technological progress， imperfect symbiotic development of the upstream and downstream of the industrial chain and unfavorable domestic and foreign agricultural policy environment. Based on this， targeted opinions and suggestions were put forward from multiple perspectives such as resource development， technological breakthrough and policy support， which provided data references and technical supports for the formulation of the national grain and oilseed development strategy.

Key words: oilseed, competitiveness, international comparison, industrial development, trade

摘要：

为进一步提升我国油料产业竞争力，推动我国油料产业高质量发展，选取2000年以来油料生产、消费与贸易数据，从绝对优势、比较优势和企业竞争力3个角度系统分析中国油料产业竞争力，并通过测算油料种植科技贡献率和贸易竞争力指数，对比分析影响中国油料产业竞争力的主要原因。结果表明，中国油料产业在绝对优势、比较优势和企业竞争力3个方面均处于劣势，资源禀赋不足、技术进步贡献偏低、产业链上下游共生发展生态不完善及国内外农业政策环境不利等是制约中国油料产业竞争力提升的主要原因。基于此，从资源开发、技术突破、政策扶持等方面提出针对性建议，以期为国家粮油发展战略的制定提供数据参考和技术支持。

关键词: 油料, 竞争力, 国际比较, 产业发展, 贸易

CLC Number:

F326

Chang CHEN, Dan GUO, Qinghong BAI, Yang ZHANG, Maolin YAN. Research on International Comparison and Development Strategy of Competitiveness of China’s Oilseed Industry[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2025, 27(4): 1-11.

陈畅, 郭丹, 白庆红, 张洋, 严茂林. 中国油料产业竞争力国际比较和发展思路研究[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2025, 27(4): 1-11.

Figures/Tables 6

References 32

1	严茂林,葛玮玮,张翔,等.我国油料产业形势分析与发展对策[J].中国油脂,2023,48(6):8-18.
	YAN M L, GE W W, ZHANG X, et al.. Situation analysis and development countermeasures of China’s oilseed industry [J].China Oils Fats,2023,48(6):8-18.
2	王明利, 鄢朝辉. 俄乌冲突对世界及我国食物安全的影响与应对策略[J]. 经济纵横,2022(7):97-106, 2.
	WANG M L, YAN Z H. The impact of the Russia-Ukraine conflict on food security in the world and China and China’s countermeasures [J]. Econ. Rev. J., 2022(7):97-106, 2.
3	王永刚,李豪强,王妍霏,等.贸易争端背景下中国油料油脂产品进口格局变化及其应对策略[J].中国油脂,2020,45(3):4-7.
	WANG Y G, LI H Q, WANG Y F, et al.. Change of China’s oilseed and oil products import pattern and its preventive solution under the background of trade dispute [J]. China Oils Fats, 2020,45(3):4-7.
4	万书波,张佳蕾.中国花生产业降本增效新途径探讨[J].中国油料作物学报,2019,41(5):657-662.
	WAN S B, ZHANG J L. Discussion on new ways to reduce cost and increase efficiency of peanut industry in China [J]. Chin. J. Oil Crop Sci.,2019,41(5):657-662.
5	李平,代洋洋,王维薇.中国主要食用油产品贸易竞争力演进态势分析[J].粮食与油脂,2019,32(7):5-9.
	LI P, DAI Y Y, WANG W W. Analysis on the evolution of trade competitiveness of China’‍s main edible oil products [J].Cereals Oils,2019,32(7):5-9.
6	钟钰,陈希,王立鹤.基于比较优势视角的中美巴三国大豆竞争力分析[J].国际贸易,2021(10):75-86.
	ZHONG Y, CHEN X, WANG L H.Analysis of soybean competitiveness among China,the United States and Brazil based on comparative advantage perspective [J]. Intertrade, 2021(10):75-86.
7	徐羽,辛良杰.中国粮食生产的国际竞争力研究[J].生态与农村环境学报,2020,36(10):1243-1250.
	XU Y, XIN L J. Research on the international competitiveness of China’s grain production [J]. J. Ecol. Rural. Environ., 2020,36(10):1243-1250.
8	何微,李俊,王晓梅,等.全球油菜产业现状与我国油菜产业问题、对策[J].中国油脂, 2022, 47(2):1-7.
	HE W, LI J, WANG X M, et al.. Current status of global rapeseed industry and problems, countermeasures of rapeseed industry in China [J]. China Oils Fats, 2022, 47(2):1-7.
9	黄季焜,解伟.中国未来食物供需展望与政策取向[J].工程管理科技前沿,2022,41(1):17-25.
	HUANG J K, XIE W. China's future food supply and demand: prospects and policies [J]. Front. Sci. Technol. Eng. Manage., 2022,41 (1): 17-25.
10	徐向梅.全面提升油料生产能力[N]. 经济日报, 2022-04-01(011).
11	中华人民共和国国家林业和草原局.中国林业和草原统计年鉴2021[M].北京：中国林业出版社，2022：33-37.
12	王瑞元.2021年我国粮油产销和进出口情况[J].中国油脂,2022,47(6):1-7.
13	中国营养学会.中国居民膳食指南（2022）[M].北京：人民卫生出版社，2022：94-95.
14	刘璐璐,李建飞,舒跃,等.我国大豆生产消费现状及提升自给率策略[J].中国油料作物学报,2022,44(2):242-248.
	LIU L L, LI J F, SHU Y, et al.. Current situation of soybean production and consumption in China and strategies to improve self-sufficiency rate [J]. Chin. J. Oil Crop Sci., 2022,44(2):242-248.
15	严茂林,施文华,周晓亮,等.基于进口视角的我国主要植物油料油脂产业安全研究[J].中国油料作物学报,2023,45(4):643-653.
	YAN M L, SHI W H, ZHOU X L, et al.. Research on industry security of China’s main oilseeds and vegetable oils from the perspective of import [J].Chin.J.Oil Crop Sci.,2023,45(4):643-653.
16	严茂林, 周晓亮, 刘自搏, 等. 我国油料增产格局及贡献因素的研究[J]. 中国油脂,2024,49(4): 1-8.
	YAN M L, ZHOU X L, LIU Z B, et al.. Pattern and Contributing factors of increasing production of oilseed in China [J]. China Oils Fats, 2024,49(4): 1-8 .
17	中华人民共和国国家统计局.中国农村统计年鉴2022[M]．北京：中国统计出版社，2022：159-242.
18	王瑞元.2020年度我国粮油加工业的基本情况[J].粮食加工,2022,47(1):1-9.
19	李丰,李光泗,郭晓东.外资进入对我国粮食安全的影响及对策[J].现代经济探讨,2011(6):49-53.
	LI F, LI G S, GUO X D.The influence and countermeasures of foreign investment to China’s grain security [J]. Mod. Econ. Res., 2011(6):49-53.
20	王欣. 益海嘉里中国本土化发展战略研究[D]. 西安:西安理工大学, 2021.
	WANG X. Research on localization strategy of Yihai Kerry in China [D]. Xi’an: Xi’an University of Technology, 2021.
21	李强. 食用油行业深度报告:稳定成长清晰格局,海外龙头指引方向[EB/OL].(2023-03-30)[2023-09-16]. .
22	中华人民共和国国家发展和改革委员会价格司.全国农产品成本收益资料汇编2021[M].北京：中国统计出版社，2021： 34-49.
23	SOLOW R. Technical change and the aggregate production function [J]. Rev. Econ. Stat., 1957, 39(3): 312-320.
24	中国证券监督管理委员会. 益海嘉里金龙鱼粮油食品股份有限公司创业板首次公开发行股票招股说明书[EB/OL].(2019-11-28) [2023-09-16]. .
25	姚林.中美贸易摩擦下的中国大豆产业现状与发展趋势[J].中国油脂,2020,45(2):10-14.
	YAO L.Current situation and development trend of China’s soybean industry under Sino-US trade friction [J].China Oils Fats,2020,45(2):10-14.
26	商务部国际司解读《区域全面经济伙伴关系协定》(RCEP)之二[EB/OL]. (2020-11-15) [2023-09-16]. .
27	石慧,王思明.相对优势地位的转变:中美大豆发展比较研究[J].中国农史,2018,37(5):56-62.
	SHI H, WANG S M. Shift of status:comparative study on the development of soybean in China and the United States [J].Agric. Hist. China, 2018,37(5):56-62.
28	李晓俐.生物能源的发展对国际及中国粮食市场的影响[J].世界农业,2010(11):4-6.
	LI X L.Impact on international and China’s food markets exerted by the development of bio-energy [J].World Agric., 2010(11):4-6.
29	朱晶,张瑞华,谢超平.全球农业贸易治理与中国粮食安全[J].农业经济问题,2022,43(11):4-17.
	ZHU J, ZHANG R H, XIE C P. Global agricultural governance and China’s food security [J]. Issu. Agric. Econ., 2022,43(11):4-17.
30	张雯丽.中国特色油料产业高质量发展思路与对策[J].中国油料作物学报,2020,42(2):167-174.
	ZHANG W L.High quality development in direction and countermeasures of specialized oil industry in China [J]. Chin. J. Oil Crop Sci., 2020,42(2):167-174.
31	李志萌,张宜红,杨志诚.乡村振兴战略背景下我国油茶产业发展研究[J].农林经济管理学报,2017,16(6):809-816.
	LI Z M, ZHANG Y H, YANG Z C. Research on the development of oil tea industry in the background of rural revitalization strategy [J]. J. Agro-For. Econ. Manage., 2017,16(6):809-816.
32	白军飞.大食物观下的食物安全保障[J].人民论坛,2023(11):56-60.

类别 Category		产量Production/10⁴ t		差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
类别 Category		2002	2021	差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
油料 Oilseed	大豆 Soybean	1 651.0	1 640.0	-11.0	-0.60
	花生 Peanut	1 481.8	1 830.8	349.0	23.60
	油菜籽 Rapeseed	1 055.2	1 471.4	416.2	39.40
	葵花籽 Sunflower seed	194.6	290.0	95.4	49.00
	芝麻 Sesame	89.5	47.7	-41.8	-46.70
	亚麻籽 Flaxseed	40.9	31.1	-9.8	-24.00
	油茶 Camellia oleifera	85.5	394.0	308.5	360.80
	核桃 Walnut	34.0	540.4	506.4	1 489.40
油脂 Oil	大豆油 Soybean oil	375.8	1 575.2	1 199.4	319.20
	菜籽油 Rapeseed oil	416.3	643.5	227.2	54.60
	花生油 Peanut oil	241.4	320.0	78.6	32.60
	玉米油 Corn oil	4.7	150.0	145.3	3 092.00
	棉籽油 Cottonseed oil	138.3	136.8	-1.5	-1.10
	葵花籽油 Sunflower oil	56.0	44.8	-11.2	-20.00
	芝麻油 Sesame oil	22.4	8.0	-14.4	-64.30
	亚麻籽油 Flaxseed oil	7.2	9.0	1.8	25.00

类别 Category		产量Production/10⁴ t		差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
类别 Category		2002	2021	差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
油料 Oilseed	大豆 Soybean	1 651.0	1 640.0	-11.0	-0.60
	花生 Peanut	1 481.8	1 830.8	349.0	23.60
	油菜籽 Rapeseed	1 055.2	1 471.4	416.2	39.40
	葵花籽 Sunflower seed	194.6	290.0	95.4	49.00
	芝麻 Sesame	89.5	47.7	-41.8	-46.70
	亚麻籽 Flaxseed	40.9	31.1	-9.8	-24.00
	油茶 Camellia oleifera	85.5	394.0	308.5	360.80
	核桃 Walnut	34.0	540.4	506.4	1 489.40
油脂 Oil	大豆油 Soybean oil	375.8	1 575.2	1 199.4	319.20
	菜籽油 Rapeseed oil	416.3	643.5	227.2	54.60
	花生油 Peanut oil	241.4	320.0	78.6	32.60
	玉米油 Corn oil	4.7	150.0	145.3	3 092.00
	棉籽油 Cottonseed oil	138.3	136.8	-1.5	-1.10
	葵花籽油 Sunflower oil	56.0	44.8	-11.2	-20.00
	芝麻油 Sesame oil	22.4	8.0	-14.4	-64.30
	亚麻籽油 Flaxseed oil	7.2	9.0	1.8	25.00

类别 Category		产量Production/10⁴ t		差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
类别 Category		2002	2021	差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
油料 Oilseed	大豆 Soybean	3 529.0	10 840.0	7 311.0	207.20
	花生 Peanut	1 372.4	1 863.8	491.4	35.80
	油菜籽 Rapeseed	1 059.9	1 701.0	641.1	60.50
	葵花籽 Sunflower seed	188.9	225.0	36.1	19.10
	棉籽 Cottonseed	986.7	1 080.0	93.3	9.50
	芝麻 Sesame	83.9	164.7	80.8	96.30
	亚麻籽 Flaxseed	40.7	73.7	33.0	81.10
油脂 Oil	大豆油 Soybean oil	638.9	1 620.0	981.1	153.60
	菜籽油 Rapeseed oil	365.8	800.0	434.2	118.70
	棕榈油 Palm oil	352.5	450.0	97.5	27.70
	花生油 Peanut oil	223.9	335.5	111.6	49.80
	棉籽油 Cottonseed oil	111.6	123.0	11.4	10.20
	葵花籽油 Sunflower oil	31.3	104.5	73.2	233.90
	棕榈仁油 Palm kernel oil	13.9	52.3	38.4	276.30

类别 Category		产量Production/10⁴ t		差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
类别 Category		2002	2021	差值 Difference/10⁴ t	变幅 Range/%
油料 Oilseed	大豆 Soybean	3 529.0	10 840.0	7 311.0	207.20
	花生 Peanut	1 372.4	1 863.8	491.4	35.80
	油菜籽 Rapeseed	1 059.9	1 701.0	641.1	60.50
	葵花籽 Sunflower seed	188.9	225.0	36.1	19.10
	棉籽 Cottonseed	986.7	1 080.0	93.3	9.50
	芝麻 Sesame	83.9	164.7	80.8	96.30
	亚麻籽 Flaxseed	40.7	73.7	33.0	81.10
油脂 Oil	大豆油 Soybean oil	638.9	1 620.0	981.1	153.60
	菜籽油 Rapeseed oil	365.8	800.0	434.2	118.70
	棕榈油 Palm oil	352.5	450.0	97.5	27.70
	花生油 Peanut oil	223.9	335.5	111.6	49.80
	棉籽油 Cottonseed oil	111.6	123.0	11.4	10.20
	葵花籽油 Sunflower oil	31.3	104.5	73.2	233.90
	棕榈仁油 Palm kernel oil	13.9	52.3	38.4	276.30

指标Index	油料/油脂 Oilseed/oil	年份 Year
指标Index	油料/油脂 Oilseed/oil	2001	2011	2016	2017	2018	2019	2020	2021
国际市场占有率 MS	大豆Soybean	0.008	0.004	0.002	0.002	0.002	0.002	0.001	0.001
	花生Peanut	0.341	0.103	0.070	0.082	0.115	0.088	0.054	0.049
	油菜籽Rapeseed	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000	0.000
	大豆油Soybean oil	0.008	0.006	0.009	0.015	0.025	0.022	0.011	0.007
	花生油Peanut oil	0.068	0.071	0.038	0.055	0.064	0.052	0.042	0.045
	菜籽油Rapeseed oil	0.020	0.001	0.001	0.003	0.002	0.002	0.001	0.000
贸易竞争力TC	大豆Soybean	-0.947	-0.989	-0.994	-0.995	-0.995	-0.995	-0.996	-0.997
	花生Peanut	0.999	0.603	-0.245	0.106	0.412	-0.099	-0.606	-0.707
	油菜籽Rapeseed	-1.000	-0.999	-0.999	-1.000	-1.000	-1.000	-0.999	-0.999
	大豆油Soybean oil	-0.820	-0.894	-0.671	-0.589	-0.352	-0.522	-0.752	-0.838
	花生油Peanut oil	0.337	-0.643	-0.714	-0.753	-0.764	-0.846	-0.884	-0.910
	菜籽油Rapeseed oil	-0.783	-0.983	-0.980	-0.942	-0.975	-0.985	0.374	0.137
显示性比较优势RCA	大豆Soybean	0.174	0.034	0.016	0.012	0.013	0.013	0.008	0.007
	花生Peanut	7.925	0.993	0.531	0.642	0.902	0.668	0.367	0.321
	油菜籽Rapeseed	0.000 3	0.000 3	0.000 8	0.000 2	0.000 2	0.000 2	0.000 3	0.000 3
	大豆油Soybean oil	0.196	0.059	0.074	0.120	0.196	0.171	0.073	0.045
	花生油Peanut oil	1.657	0.681	0.293	0.433	0.501	0.395	0.287	0.298
	菜籽油Rapeseed oil	0.493	0.007	0.006	0.023	0.018	0.012	0.003	0.002
显示性竞争力RC	大豆Soybean	-3.600	-5.211	-6.041	-6.262	-6.054	-6.125	-6.573	-6.579
	花生Peanut	7.682	1.312	-0.820	0.061	0.819	-0.429	-1.676	-1.935
	油菜籽Rapeseed	-9.883	-7.677	-7.621	-9.420	-9.351	-8.536	-8.254	-8.080
	大豆油Soybean oil	-2.393	-3.000	-1.962	-1.595	-1.035	-1.491	-2.321	-2.984
	花生油Peanut oil	0.655	-1.423	-2.539	-2.071	-1.893	-2.445	-3.002	-2.922
	菜籽油Rapeseed oil	-2.253	-4.903	-4.919	-3.731	-4.467	-5.060	0.566	0.111