Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology ›› 2022, Vol. 24 ›› Issue (3): 57-66.DOI: 10.13304/j.nykjdb.2020.1011
• BIOTECHNOLOGY & LIFE SCIENCE • Previous Articles Next Articles
Qijun BAO1(), Yongdong PAN1(), Huayu ZHANG1, Xiaoning LIU1, Dongjia ZHANG1, Feng ZHAO1, Xiaoxia NIU1, Jun CHEN2
Received:
2020-11-30
Accepted:
2021-04-11
Online:
2022-03-15
Published:
2022-03-14
Contact:
Yongdong PAN
包奇军1(), 潘永东1(), 张华瑜1, 柳小宁1, 张东佳1, 赵锋1, 牛小霞1, 陈军2
通讯作者:
潘永东
作者简介:
包奇军 E-mail:baoqijun78@163.com;
基金资助:
CLC Number:
Qijun BAO, Yongdong PAN, Huayu ZHANG, Xiaoning LIU, Dongjia ZHANG, Feng ZHAO, Xiaoxia NIU, Jun CHEN. Analysis of Agronomic and Quality Characters of Beer Barley from Gansu and Europe, North America[J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 57-66.
包奇军, 潘永东, 张华瑜, 柳小宁, 张东佳, 赵锋, 牛小霞, 陈军. 甘肃与欧洲、北美啤酒大麦品种农艺及品质性状比较分析[J]. 中国农业科技导报, 2022, 24(3): 57-66.
品种 Variety | 棱形 Row-type | 来源 Origin | 品种 Variety | 棱形 Row-type | 来源 Origin |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
M-22 | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z014J081J | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.SZOFI | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | MERIT | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.DAMA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z109M050M | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.LEDI | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | PRESTIGE | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.GYONGYOS | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z090M066M | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
Jubilant | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | G231M004M | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Jaxana | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | TRADITION | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Raxana | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | B1614 | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Qinta | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 6B98-9339 | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Jubelete | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 法瓦维特 Favavit | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃 Gansu |
TABORA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 2号 Ganpi 2 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
ROXANA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 3号Ganpi 3 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
SCARLETT | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 4号Ganpi 4 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Pasadena | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 5号Ganpi 5 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Marnie | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 6号Ganpi 6 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Z053N066N | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America | 甘啤 7号Ganpi 7 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
B1202 | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
Table 1 Origin of the 33 barley accessions used in this study
品种 Variety | 棱形 Row-type | 来源 Origin | 品种 Variety | 棱形 Row-type | 来源 Origin |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
M-22 | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z014J081J | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.SZOFI | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | MERIT | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.DAMA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z109M050M | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.LEDI | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | PRESTIGE | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
KH.GYONGYOS | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | Z090M066M | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
Jubilant | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | G231M004M | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Jaxana | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | TRADITION | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Raxana | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | B1614 | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Qinta | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 6B98-9339 | 多棱 Multi-row | 北美 North America |
Jubelete | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 法瓦维特 Favavit | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃 Gansu |
TABORA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 2号 Ganpi 2 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
ROXANA | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 3号Ganpi 3 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
SCARLETT | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 4号Ganpi 4 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Pasadena | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 5号Ganpi 5 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Marnie | 二棱 Two-row | 欧洲 Europe | 甘啤 6号Ganpi 6 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
Z053N066N | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America | 甘啤 7号Ganpi 7 | 二棱 Two-row | 甘肃Gansu |
B1202 | 二棱 Two-row | 北美 North America |
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 生育期 Growth period/d | 株高 Plant height/cm | 穗长 Ear length/cm | 穗茎节 Ear node/cm | 茎节长度 Stem height/cm | 株穗数 Panicles per plant | 株粒数 Seeds per plant | 单株粒重 Seed weight per plant/g | 穗重 Grain weight per panicle/g | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st | 2nd | ||||||||||
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 97.0~101.0 | 72.0~91.3 | 6.4~8.6 | 20.4~29.4 | 1.6~2.3 | 5.0~8.0 | 2.5~4.1 | 62.8~87.0 | 3.1~4.1 | 0.8~1.3 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±1.66 | 77.70±6.04 | 7.7±0.73 | 23.80±2.99 | 1.90±0.32 | 6.20±1.02 | 3.30±0.53 | 75.60±11.80 | 3.60±0.57 | 1.10±0.14 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.014 5 | 0.064 8 | 0.081 8 | 0.114 7 | 0.093 1 | 0.112 9 | 0.126 0 | 0.100 3 | 0.084 8 | 0.108 5 | |
F 值 F value | 4.388** | 4.272** | 6.197** | 8.142** | 0.963 | 1.781 | 2.858** | 1.405 | 0.843 | 4.236** | |
北美大麦 (二棱) North American barley(Two-row) | 变幅 Range | 97.0~102.0 | 73.1~97.3 | 7.0~8.4 | 20.7~32.0 | 1.9~2.4 | 6.3~8.4 | 3.1~3.8 | 69.9~97.6 | 3.3~4.7 | 1.0~1.4 |
平均 Mean | 100.00±1.63 | 86.50±9.70 | 7.7±0.67 | 26.90±4.79** | 2.20±0.34 | 7.50±0.95 | 3.40±0.33 | 79.80±12.15 | 4.00±0.66 | 1.20±0.19 | |
变异系数CV/% | 0.015 2 | 0.110 7 | 0.069 7 | 0.173 1 | 0.094 8 | 0.111 7 | 0.064 8 | 0.124 9 | 0.128 2 | 0.110 8 | |
F 值 F value | 16.300** | 16.774** | 3.157* | 12.525** | 0.997 | 1.861 | 1.132 | 3.600* | 3.030* | 1.333 | |
北美大麦 (多棱) North American barley(multi-row) | 变幅 Range | 96.0~101.0 | 70.4~94.7 | 5.4~6.8 | 26.9~40.4 | 1.5~2.2 | 4.4~6.3 | 2.1~2.5 | 79.0~123.1 | 3.8~5.4 | 1.7~2.0 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±2.45 | 88.30±12.31 | 6.30±0.64 | 34.10±5.84 | 2.00±0.51 | 5.60±1.07 | 2.30±0.43 | 98.10±24.33 | 4.50±0.99 | 2.00±0.25 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.024 7 | 0.135 3 | 0.103 3 | 0.174 7 | 0.168 3 | 0.147 5 | 0.075 1 | 0.197 8 | 0.149 8 | 0.088 8 | |
F值 F value | 9.333** | 8.995** | 8.687** | 15.470** | 1.239 | 2.561 | 0.506 | 2.899 | 1.688 | 2.529 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 95.0~100.0 | 68.0~89.6 | 7.3~8.8 | 23.6~29.2 | 1.2~2.1 | 4.3~5.9 | 2.7~3.3 | 44.6~76.3 | 3.3~4.0 | 1.0~1.3 |
平均 Mean | 98.00±2.10 | 78.70±8.39 | 8.00±0.75 | 25.5±2.75 | 1.70±0.42 | 5.30±0.71 | 3.00±0.37 | 67.20±20.60 | 3.60±0.58 | 1.20±0.20 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.021 2 | 0.094 4 | 0.069 9 | 0.088 3 | 0.182 1 | 0.113 7 | 0.069 3 | 0.152 2 | 0.057 8 | 0.096 2 | |
F 值 F value | 49.333** | 4.669** | 1.844 | 2.699 | 2.375 | 1.106 | 1.548 | 0.846 | 0.100 | 1.420 | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 95.0~102.0 | 68.0~97.3 | 5.4~8.8 | 20.4~40.4 | 1.2~2.4 | 4.3~8.4 | 2.1~4.1 | 44.6~123.1 | 3.1~5.4 | 0.8~2.1 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±1.92 | 81.10±9.28 | 7.60±0.87 | 26.00±4.96 | 1.90±0.39 | 6.20±1.19 | 3.10±0.57 | 77.40±18.33 | 3.80±0.70 | 1.30±0.32 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.017 5 | 0.104 4 | 0.102 5 | 0.181 6 | 0.138 9 | 0.167 5 | 0.149 8 | 0.172 0 | 0.124 3 | 0.230 4 | |
F 值 F value | 9.320** | 8.756** | 7.740** | 15.721** | 1.720* | 4.628** | 4.319** | 2.715** | 1.674* | 11.147** |
Table 2 Agronomy characters of varieties from different origins
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 生育期 Growth period/d | 株高 Plant height/cm | 穗长 Ear length/cm | 穗茎节 Ear node/cm | 茎节长度 Stem height/cm | 株穗数 Panicles per plant | 株粒数 Seeds per plant | 单株粒重 Seed weight per plant/g | 穗重 Grain weight per panicle/g | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st | 2nd | ||||||||||
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 97.0~101.0 | 72.0~91.3 | 6.4~8.6 | 20.4~29.4 | 1.6~2.3 | 5.0~8.0 | 2.5~4.1 | 62.8~87.0 | 3.1~4.1 | 0.8~1.3 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±1.66 | 77.70±6.04 | 7.7±0.73 | 23.80±2.99 | 1.90±0.32 | 6.20±1.02 | 3.30±0.53 | 75.60±11.80 | 3.60±0.57 | 1.10±0.14 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.014 5 | 0.064 8 | 0.081 8 | 0.114 7 | 0.093 1 | 0.112 9 | 0.126 0 | 0.100 3 | 0.084 8 | 0.108 5 | |
F 值 F value | 4.388** | 4.272** | 6.197** | 8.142** | 0.963 | 1.781 | 2.858** | 1.405 | 0.843 | 4.236** | |
北美大麦 (二棱) North American barley(Two-row) | 变幅 Range | 97.0~102.0 | 73.1~97.3 | 7.0~8.4 | 20.7~32.0 | 1.9~2.4 | 6.3~8.4 | 3.1~3.8 | 69.9~97.6 | 3.3~4.7 | 1.0~1.4 |
平均 Mean | 100.00±1.63 | 86.50±9.70 | 7.7±0.67 | 26.90±4.79** | 2.20±0.34 | 7.50±0.95 | 3.40±0.33 | 79.80±12.15 | 4.00±0.66 | 1.20±0.19 | |
变异系数CV/% | 0.015 2 | 0.110 7 | 0.069 7 | 0.173 1 | 0.094 8 | 0.111 7 | 0.064 8 | 0.124 9 | 0.128 2 | 0.110 8 | |
F 值 F value | 16.300** | 16.774** | 3.157* | 12.525** | 0.997 | 1.861 | 1.132 | 3.600* | 3.030* | 1.333 | |
北美大麦 (多棱) North American barley(multi-row) | 变幅 Range | 96.0~101.0 | 70.4~94.7 | 5.4~6.8 | 26.9~40.4 | 1.5~2.2 | 4.4~6.3 | 2.1~2.5 | 79.0~123.1 | 3.8~5.4 | 1.7~2.0 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±2.45 | 88.30±12.31 | 6.30±0.64 | 34.10±5.84 | 2.00±0.51 | 5.60±1.07 | 2.30±0.43 | 98.10±24.33 | 4.50±0.99 | 2.00±0.25 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.024 7 | 0.135 3 | 0.103 3 | 0.174 7 | 0.168 3 | 0.147 5 | 0.075 1 | 0.197 8 | 0.149 8 | 0.088 8 | |
F值 F value | 9.333** | 8.995** | 8.687** | 15.470** | 1.239 | 2.561 | 0.506 | 2.899 | 1.688 | 2.529 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 95.0~100.0 | 68.0~89.6 | 7.3~8.8 | 23.6~29.2 | 1.2~2.1 | 4.3~5.9 | 2.7~3.3 | 44.6~76.3 | 3.3~4.0 | 1.0~1.3 |
平均 Mean | 98.00±2.10 | 78.70±8.39 | 8.00±0.75 | 25.5±2.75 | 1.70±0.42 | 5.30±0.71 | 3.00±0.37 | 67.20±20.60 | 3.60±0.58 | 1.20±0.20 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.021 2 | 0.094 4 | 0.069 9 | 0.088 3 | 0.182 1 | 0.113 7 | 0.069 3 | 0.152 2 | 0.057 8 | 0.096 2 | |
F 值 F value | 49.333** | 4.669** | 1.844 | 2.699 | 2.375 | 1.106 | 1.548 | 0.846 | 0.100 | 1.420 | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 95.0~102.0 | 68.0~97.3 | 5.4~8.8 | 20.4~40.4 | 1.2~2.4 | 4.3~8.4 | 2.1~4.1 | 44.6~123.1 | 3.1~5.4 | 0.8~2.1 |
平均 Mean | 99.00±1.92 | 81.10±9.28 | 7.60±0.87 | 26.00±4.96 | 1.90±0.39 | 6.20±1.19 | 3.10±0.57 | 77.40±18.33 | 3.80±0.70 | 1.30±0.32 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.017 5 | 0.104 4 | 0.102 5 | 0.181 6 | 0.138 9 | 0.167 5 | 0.149 8 | 0.172 0 | 0.124 3 | 0.230 4 | |
F 值 F value | 9.320** | 8.756** | 7.740** | 15.721** | 1.720* | 4.628** | 4.319** | 2.715** | 1.674* | 11.147** |
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 基本苗 Basic seedling/(104·hm-2) | 成穗数 Ear number/(104·hm-2) | 千粒重 1 000-grain weight/g | 穗粒数 Seeds per ear | 产量 Yield/ (kg·hm-2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 274.65~335.25 | 574.95~879.75 | 42.5~49.5 | 20.0~25.2 | 9 086.17~7 726.10 |
平均 Mean | 303.28±21.52 | 752.40±105.29 | 45.0±2.52 | 23.0±1.81 | 8 566.52±511.85 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.053 4 | 0.115 3 | 0.043 3 | 0.070 9 | 0.054 1 | |
F 值 F value | 2.524* | 3.935** | 2.836** | 7.421** | 3.227** | |
北美大麦(二棱) North American barley (Two-row) | 变幅 Range | 266.40~328.20 | 672.00~883.05 | 44.1~51.3 | 20.6~29.6 | 9 223.32~8 126.12 |
平均 Mean | 293.49±29.33 | 772.26±94.54 | 46.67±2.46 | 23.64±3.15 | 8 733.49±514.90 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.070 0 | 0.102 8 | 0.052 3 | 0.125 5 | 0.043 1 | |
F 值 F value | 1.860 | 4.046* | 20.839** | 9.717** | 1.340 | |
北美大麦(多棱) North American barley (Multi-row) | 变幅 Range | 242.70~298.65 | 400.20~516.00 | 38.5~46.8 | 35.1~48.9 | 8 754.72~8 274.70 |
平均 Mean | 281.66±28.71 | 436.39±73.46 | 42.43±3.14 | 43.23±7.42 | 8 451.85±427.94 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.094 4 | 0.123 0 | 0.081 2 | 0.144 8 | 0.024 8 | |
F 值 F value | 6.312* | 2.069 | 118.207** | 3.704 | 0.453 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 270.90~355.65 | 582.60~826.65 | 41.1~51.7 | 22.0~26.0 | 9 364.28~7 714.67 |
平均 Mean | 306.45±31.45 | 686.51±108.97 | 47.16±3.84 | 23.86±1.99 | 8 557.71±700.78 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.096 0 | 0.117 3 | 0.083 9 | 0.060 6 | 0.078 9 | |
F 值 F value | 8.651** | 2.258 | 46.936** | 2.075 | 3.334* | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 242.70~355.65 | 400.20~883.05 | 38.5~51.7 | 20.0~48.9 | 9 364.28~7 714.67 |
平均 Mean | 299.25±27.23 | 704.33±144.01 | 45.51±3.22 | 25.81±7.27 | 8 586.17±549.18 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.073 8 | 0.185 6 | 0.066 0 | 0.274 4 | 0.054 3 | |
F 值 F value | 3.741** | 8.644** | 11.947** | 27.138** | 2.376** |
Table 3 Yield of varieties from different origins
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 基本苗 Basic seedling/(104·hm-2) | 成穗数 Ear number/(104·hm-2) | 千粒重 1 000-grain weight/g | 穗粒数 Seeds per ear | 产量 Yield/ (kg·hm-2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 274.65~335.25 | 574.95~879.75 | 42.5~49.5 | 20.0~25.2 | 9 086.17~7 726.10 |
平均 Mean | 303.28±21.52 | 752.40±105.29 | 45.0±2.52 | 23.0±1.81 | 8 566.52±511.85 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.053 4 | 0.115 3 | 0.043 3 | 0.070 9 | 0.054 1 | |
F 值 F value | 2.524* | 3.935** | 2.836** | 7.421** | 3.227** | |
北美大麦(二棱) North American barley (Two-row) | 变幅 Range | 266.40~328.20 | 672.00~883.05 | 44.1~51.3 | 20.6~29.6 | 9 223.32~8 126.12 |
平均 Mean | 293.49±29.33 | 772.26±94.54 | 46.67±2.46 | 23.64±3.15 | 8 733.49±514.90 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.070 0 | 0.102 8 | 0.052 3 | 0.125 5 | 0.043 1 | |
F 值 F value | 1.860 | 4.046* | 20.839** | 9.717** | 1.340 | |
北美大麦(多棱) North American barley (Multi-row) | 变幅 Range | 242.70~298.65 | 400.20~516.00 | 38.5~46.8 | 35.1~48.9 | 8 754.72~8 274.70 |
平均 Mean | 281.66±28.71 | 436.39±73.46 | 42.43±3.14 | 43.23±7.42 | 8 451.85±427.94 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.094 4 | 0.123 0 | 0.081 2 | 0.144 8 | 0.024 8 | |
F 值 F value | 6.312* | 2.069 | 118.207** | 3.704 | 0.453 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 270.90~355.65 | 582.60~826.65 | 41.1~51.7 | 22.0~26.0 | 9 364.28~7 714.67 |
平均 Mean | 306.45±31.45 | 686.51±108.97 | 47.16±3.84 | 23.86±1.99 | 8 557.71±700.78 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.096 0 | 0.117 3 | 0.083 9 | 0.060 6 | 0.078 9 | |
F 值 F value | 8.651** | 2.258 | 46.936** | 2.075 | 3.334* | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 242.70~355.65 | 400.20~883.05 | 38.5~51.7 | 20.0~48.9 | 9 364.28~7 714.67 |
平均 Mean | 299.25±27.23 | 704.33±144.01 | 45.51±3.22 | 25.81±7.27 | 8 586.17±549.18 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.073 8 | 0.185 6 | 0.066 0 | 0.274 4 | 0.054 3 | |
F 值 F value | 3.741** | 8.644** | 11.947** | 27.138** | 2.376** |
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 蛋白质含量 Protein content/% | 饱满度(≥2.5 mm) Screening rate(≥2.5 mm)/% |
---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 9.8~11.3 | 86.2~94.6 |
平均值 Mean | 10.46±0.56 | 91.5±3.01 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.036 1 | 0.029 7 | |
F 值 F value | 1.562 | 7.653** | |
北美大麦 North American barley | 变幅 Range | 10.0~11.0 | 83.2~93.8 |
平均值 Mean | 10.47±0.47 | 88.5±4.81 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.031 7 | 0.038 4 | |
F 值 F value | 1.950 | 1.941 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 10~11.2 | 82.7~95.9 |
平均值 Mean | 10.64±0.53 | 90.6±4.79 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.040 2 | 0.050 8 | |
F 值 F value | 3.184* | 11.380** | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 9.8~11.3 | 82.7~95.9 |
平均值 Mean | 10.50±0.52 | 90.3±4.25 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.035 2 | 0.039 3 | |
F 值 F value | 1.901* | 4.473** |
Table 4 Quality of varieties from different origins
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 蛋白质含量 Protein content/% | 饱满度(≥2.5 mm) Screening rate(≥2.5 mm)/% |
---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 9.8~11.3 | 86.2~94.6 |
平均值 Mean | 10.46±0.56 | 91.5±3.01 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.036 1 | 0.029 7 | |
F 值 F value | 1.562 | 7.653** | |
北美大麦 North American barley | 变幅 Range | 10.0~11.0 | 83.2~93.8 |
平均值 Mean | 10.47±0.47 | 88.5±4.81 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.031 7 | 0.038 4 | |
F 值 F value | 1.950 | 1.941 | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 10~11.2 | 82.7~95.9 |
平均值 Mean | 10.64±0.53 | 90.6±4.79 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.040 2 | 0.050 8 | |
F 值 F value | 3.184* | 11.380** | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 9.8~11.3 | 82.7~95.9 |
平均值 Mean | 10.50±0.52 | 90.3±4.25 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.035 2 | 0.039 3 | |
F 值 F value | 1.901* | 4.473** |
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 水分含量 Moisture content/% | 蛋白质含量 Protein content/% | 可溶性氮 Soluble nitrogen/% | 库值 Kolbach index/% | 浊度 Turbidity/ EBC | 细粉浸出物 Fine powder extract/% | α-氨基氮 α-amino nitrogen/ (mg·100 g-1) | β-葡聚糖 β-glucanase/ (mg·100 g-1) | α-淀粉酶α-amylase/DU | 糖化力 Diastatic power/WK |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 3.1~3.8 | 8.6~11.2 | 3.9~5.4 | 36.5~62.4 | 0.9~9.0 | 76.2~81.8 | 146.2~244.9 | 85.8~408.6 | 37.2~71.3 | 273.3~459.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.4±0.22 | 9.6±0.83 | 4.8±0.46 | 51.1±6.65 | 3.0±2.62 | 80.5±1.60 | 201.6±29.06 | 203.3±90.96 | 53.8±9.88 | 353.5±57.47 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.051 4 | 0.079 2 | 0.086 5 | 0.132 8 | 0.895 8 | 0.017 8 | 0.142 8 | 0.454 2 | 0.186 5 | 0.166 2 | |
F 值 F value | 3.450** | 8.675** | 8.870** | 289.780** | 377.259** | 7.122** | 31.801** | 127.788** | 143.291** | 843.382** | |
北美大麦 North American barley | 变幅 Range | 3.1~3.5 | 8.0~10.3 | 4.1~5.8 | 40.5~63.7 | 0.7~5.7 | 72.3~81.9 | 156.6~304.2 | 123.4~372.1 | 43.1~77.4 | 258.9~468.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.3±0.16 | 9.4±0.78 | 4.9±0.56 | 51.9±6.86 | 2.0±1.77 | 79.9±2.60 | 211.5±42.66 | 239.2±80.16 | 56.4±9.82 | 367.5±68.38 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.035 2 | 0.078 1 | 0.103 7 | 0.135 7 | 0.929 5 | 0.032 8 | 0.207 0 | 0.323 2 | 0.178 9 | 0.191 9 | |
F 值 F value | 2.250* | 11.396** | 7.368** | 201.587** | 247.555** | 48.447** | 167.767** | 15.010** | 245.793** | 706.332** | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 3.3~5.2 | 8.9~12.3 | 4.1~5.3 | 38.5~59.2 | 0.7~9.9 | 80.0~82.6 | 129.2~246.2 | 82.3~397.8 | 46.8~58.2 | 283.9~401.7 |
平均 Mean | 3.9±0.69 | 10.2±1.17 | 4.6±0.49 | 46.1±6.96 | 3.3±3.22 | 81.4±1.17 | 187.6±52.19 | 254.1±97.99 | 51.2±4.28 | 352.9±49.28 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.172 3 | 0.116 8 | 0.094 6 | 0.157 7 | 1.028 1 | 0.011 9 | 0.229 6 | 0.405 7 | 0.086 3 | 0.146 2 | |
F 值 F value | 13.841** | 31.723** | 6.328* | 108.144** | 1 098.687** | 3.702* | 3.693* | 531.798** | 57.318** | 167.377** | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 3.1~5.2 | 8.0~12.3 | 3.9~5.8 | 36.5~63.7 | 0.7~9.9 | 72.3~82.6 | 129.2~304.2 | 82.3~408.6 | 37.2~77.4 | 258.9~468.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.5±0.42 | 9.7±0.93 | 4.8±0.50 | 50.3±7.08 | 2.7±2.55 | 80.5±1.97 | 201.9±40.05 | 226.0±90.76 | 54.1±9.09 | 358.1±59.58 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.003 2 | 0.091 1 | 0.093 0 | 0.141 5 | 0.950 4 | 0.023 2 | 0.184 4 | 0.397 3 | 0.168 5 | 0.167 8 | |
F 值 F value | 11.949** | 13.968** | 7.414 | 196.639** | 433.614** | 14.978** | 11.343** | 48.196** | 157.086** | 476.143** |
Table 5 Malt quality of varieties from different origins
材料 Material | 参数 Parameter | 水分含量 Moisture content/% | 蛋白质含量 Protein content/% | 可溶性氮 Soluble nitrogen/% | 库值 Kolbach index/% | 浊度 Turbidity/ EBC | 细粉浸出物 Fine powder extract/% | α-氨基氮 α-amino nitrogen/ (mg·100 g-1) | β-葡聚糖 β-glucanase/ (mg·100 g-1) | α-淀粉酶α-amylase/DU | 糖化力 Diastatic power/WK |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
欧洲大麦 European barley | 变幅 Range | 3.1~3.8 | 8.6~11.2 | 3.9~5.4 | 36.5~62.4 | 0.9~9.0 | 76.2~81.8 | 146.2~244.9 | 85.8~408.6 | 37.2~71.3 | 273.3~459.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.4±0.22 | 9.6±0.83 | 4.8±0.46 | 51.1±6.65 | 3.0±2.62 | 80.5±1.60 | 201.6±29.06 | 203.3±90.96 | 53.8±9.88 | 353.5±57.47 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.051 4 | 0.079 2 | 0.086 5 | 0.132 8 | 0.895 8 | 0.017 8 | 0.142 8 | 0.454 2 | 0.186 5 | 0.166 2 | |
F 值 F value | 3.450** | 8.675** | 8.870** | 289.780** | 377.259** | 7.122** | 31.801** | 127.788** | 143.291** | 843.382** | |
北美大麦 North American barley | 变幅 Range | 3.1~3.5 | 8.0~10.3 | 4.1~5.8 | 40.5~63.7 | 0.7~5.7 | 72.3~81.9 | 156.6~304.2 | 123.4~372.1 | 43.1~77.4 | 258.9~468.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.3±0.16 | 9.4±0.78 | 4.9±0.56 | 51.9±6.86 | 2.0±1.77 | 79.9±2.60 | 211.5±42.66 | 239.2±80.16 | 56.4±9.82 | 367.5±68.38 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.035 2 | 0.078 1 | 0.103 7 | 0.135 7 | 0.929 5 | 0.032 8 | 0.207 0 | 0.323 2 | 0.178 9 | 0.191 9 | |
F 值 F value | 2.250* | 11.396** | 7.368** | 201.587** | 247.555** | 48.447** | 167.767** | 15.010** | 245.793** | 706.332** | |
甘肃大麦 Gansu barley | 变幅 Range | 3.3~5.2 | 8.9~12.3 | 4.1~5.3 | 38.5~59.2 | 0.7~9.9 | 80.0~82.6 | 129.2~246.2 | 82.3~397.8 | 46.8~58.2 | 283.9~401.7 |
平均 Mean | 3.9±0.69 | 10.2±1.17 | 4.6±0.49 | 46.1±6.96 | 3.3±3.22 | 81.4±1.17 | 187.6±52.19 | 254.1±97.99 | 51.2±4.28 | 352.9±49.28 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.172 3 | 0.116 8 | 0.094 6 | 0.157 7 | 1.028 1 | 0.011 9 | 0.229 6 | 0.405 7 | 0.086 3 | 0.146 2 | |
F 值 F value | 13.841** | 31.723** | 6.328* | 108.144** | 1 098.687** | 3.702* | 3.693* | 531.798** | 57.318** | 167.377** | |
总计 Total | 变幅 Range | 3.1~5.2 | 8.0~12.3 | 3.9~5.8 | 36.5~63.7 | 0.7~9.9 | 72.3~82.6 | 129.2~304.2 | 82.3~408.6 | 37.2~77.4 | 258.9~468.8 |
平均 Mean | 3.5±0.42 | 9.7±0.93 | 4.8±0.50 | 50.3±7.08 | 2.7±2.55 | 80.5±1.97 | 201.9±40.05 | 226.0±90.76 | 54.1±9.09 | 358.1±59.58 | |
变异系数 CV/% | 0.003 2 | 0.091 1 | 0.093 0 | 0.141 5 | 0.950 4 | 0.023 2 | 0.184 4 | 0.397 3 | 0.168 5 | 0.167 8 | |
F 值 F value | 11.949** | 13.968** | 7.414 | 196.639** | 433.614** | 14.978** | 11.343** | 48.196** | 157.086** | 476.143** |
1 | 边秀秀,李志兰,任红艳,等.我国大麦产业发展现状和遗传育种研究重点趋势分析[J].生物技术进展,2012,2(5):309-314. |
BIAN X X, LI Z L, REN H Y, et al.. Development status and genetic breeding research priorities of barley in China [J]. Curr. Biotechnol., 2012,2(5):309-314. | |
2 | 程燕.基于产业链视角的中国啤酒大麦产业发展研究[D].北京:中国农业科学院,2013. |
CHENG Y. Study on the development of malting barley industry in China on the perspective of industry chain [D]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, 2013. | |
3 | 魏胜文,乔德华,张东伟.甘肃农业科技发展研究报告(2011—2015) [M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2016:1-614. |
WEI X W, QIAO D H, ZHANG D W. Report on Agricultural Science and Technology of Gansu (2011—2015) [M]. Beijing: Soclal Sciences Academic Press, 2016:1-614. | |
4 | 张赤红,张京.大麦品种资源遗传多样性的SSR标记评价[J].麦类作物学报,2008,28(2):214-219. |
ZHANG C H, ZHANG J. Genetic diversity assessment of barley germplasm resources using SSR markers [J]. J. Triticeae Crops, 2008, 28(2):214-219. | |
5 | 何庆祥,黄乐珊.欧美大麦种质资源在甘肃的生态适应性评价[J].草业科学,2008(8):35-39. |
HE Q X, HUANG L S. Evaluation on the ecological adaptability of barley germplasm from Europe and America in Gansu Province [J]. Pratac. Sci., 2008(8):35-39. | |
6 | 王荣栋,塞福鼎,司马义,等.啤酒大麦法瓦维特生育特性研究[J].新疆农业科学,1999(5):193-195. |
WANG R D, SAI F D, SI M Y, et al.. Study on the growth characteristics of favavit in beer barley [J]. Xinjiang Agric. Sci., 1999(5):193-195. | |
7 | 李洁,李作安,许文之,等.北美啤酒大麦品种的引种鉴定与利用[J].中国种业,2004,(6):42. |
LI J, LI Z A, XU Z W, et al.. Evaluating of introduction and utilization of the American barley varieties [J]. China Seeds, 2004(6):42. | |
8 | 杨勇.青藏高原一年生野生大麦的农艺性状及品质性状分析[D].武汉:华中农业大学,2010. |
YANG Y. Analysis of agronomic and quality traits in the annual wild barely accessions of Qing-Tibetan Plateau [D]. Wuhan: Huazhong Agricultural University, 2010. | |
9 | 杨振华.甘啤系列啤酒大麦品种(系)与国外引进品种遗传多样性的SSR分析[D].兰州:甘肃农业大学,2009. |
YANG Z H. Analysis of genetic diversity on beer barley between Ganpi series arieties (lines) and imported varieties [D]. Lanzhou:Gansu Agricultural University, 2009. | |
10 | ABDUL W K B. Assessment of genetic dicersity in barley germplasm and sequencing of Ppd-H1 gene for genetic variation in natural populations of barley from Middle East [D]. Shaanxi Yangling: Northwest A & F University, 2013. |
11 | 包奇军,潘永东,张华瑜,等.美国引进酿造专用啤酒大麦产量及品质综合分析[J].中国酿造,2016,35(8):73-77. |
BAO Q J, PAN Y D, ZHANG H Y, et al.. Comprehensive analysis of yield and quality of American malting barley cultivars [J]. China Brewing, 2016, 35(8):73-77. | |
12 | 包奇军,潘永东,张华瑜,等.9份欧洲引进啤酒大麦的产量及品质分析[J].麦类作物学报,2016,36(4):449-454. |
BAO Q J, PAN Y D, ZHANG H Y, et al.. Yield and quality analysis of nine European malting barley cultivars [J]. J. Triticeae Crops, 2016, 36(4):449-454. | |
13 | 包奇军.甘啤系列啤酒大麦主要性状遗传差异及演变规律研究[J].中国种业,2012,4,36-38. |
BAO Q J. Research of main characters genetic differences and evolution of main traits on barley of Ganpi series varieties [J]. China Seeds, 2012(4):36-38. | |
14 | 刘三才,朱志华,张京,等.北美不同棱型大麦种质资源品质分析[J].植物遗传资源学报, 2004,5(2):139-141. |
LIU S C, ZHU Z H, ZHANG J, et al.. Evaluation of quality traits between the two and six-rowed barley from American [J]. J. Plant Genet. Resour., 2004, 5(2):139-141. | |
15 | 张京,刘旭.大麦种质资源描述规范和数据标准[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2006:1-70. |
ZHANG J, LIU X. Descriptors and Data Standard for Barley (Hordeumvulgare L.) [M]. Beijing: China Agricultural Press, 2006:1-70. | |
16 | 张小燕,张跃进,庞有强.日本大麦种质资源鉴定评价[J].西北农业学报,2009,18(6):128-132. |
ZHANG X Y, ZHANG Y J, PANG Y Q. Evaluation on barley germplasm from Japan [J]. Acta Agric. Bor-Occid. Sin., 2009, 18(6):122-126. | |
17 | 孙立军.国外大麦种质资源引种及其利用[J].作物品种资源,1998,1:37-40. |
18 | 王效宗.外引大麦品种主要性状分析及我省啤酒大麦引种途径初探[J].甘肃农业科技,1989(3):11-14. |
19 | 解松峰,欧行奇,张百忍,等.大麦引进种质资源表型的多样性与模糊聚类分析[J].干旱地区农业研究, 2010(05):11-20. |
XIE S F, OU X Q, ZHANG B R, et al.. Phenotypic diversity analysis and fuzzy clustering in barley germplasm resources introduced from abroad [J]. Agric. Res. Arid Areas, 2010, 28(5):6-14. | |
20 | 赵金枝,王树杰,郜战宁,等.大麦品种资源的研究与利用[J].大麦科学, 2005(4):14-17. |
ZHAO J Z, WANG S J, GAO Z N, et al.. Research and utilization of barley source [J]. Barley Sci., 2005(4):14-17. | |
21 | 李喜焕,常文锁,张彩英,等.引进秋播啤酒大麦不同播期、密度与产量的关系研究[J].河北农业大学学报,2008,31(1):6-11. |
LI X H, CHANG W S, ZHANG C Y, et al.. Relations between sowing date, seeding density and grain yield of two introduced malting barley varieties [J]. J. Agric. Univ. Heibei, 2008, 31(1):6-11. | |
22 | WANG J P, RAMAN H, ZHANG G P, et al.. Aluminium tolerance in barley (hordeumvulgare. L): physiological mechanisms, genetics and screening methods [J]. J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci. B, 2006, 7(10):769-787. |
23 | WANG J M, YANG J M, ZHU J H. Assessment of genetic diversity by simple sequence repeat markers anong forty elite varieties in the germplasm for malting barley breeding [J]. J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci., 2010, 11(10):792-800. |
24 | 吕仲昱,马永强,王效宗,等.优质高产啤酒大麦新品种陇啤1号的选育[J].大麦与谷类科学,2011(3):6-12. |
25 | 尤艳蓉,孟亚雄,李葆春,等.十个外引啤酒大麦品种产量及品质分析[J]. 麦类作物学报,2012, 32(4):762-766. |
YOU Y R, MENG Y X, LI B C, et al.. Analysis of yield and quality of ten introduced malting barley cultivars [J]. J. Triticeae Crops, 2012, 32(4):762-766. | |
26 | 李喜焕,常文锁,张彩英,等.引进秋播啤酒大麦不同播期,密度与产量的关系研究[J].河北农业大学学报,2008,31(1):6-11. |
LI X H, CHANG W S, ZHANG C Y, et al.. Relations between sowing date, seeding density and grain yield of two introduced malting barley varieties [J]. J. Agric. Univ. Heibei, 2008, 31(1):6-11. |
[1] | Xuezhen XIONG, Chun YANG, Xiaoping MA. Situation of China's Animal Husbandry Development and High-quality Development Strategy Selection [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 1-10. |
[2] | Tianming QI, Zhijian LI, Peiyou QIN, Guixing REN, Bangwei ZHOU. Research and Application Prospect of Quinoa Cultivation Technology [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 157-165. |
[3] | Linlin DONG, Jinfang ZHA, Mingxing SHEN, Haihou WANG, Linlin SHI, Yueyue TAO, Xinwei ZHOU, Changying LU. Effect of Long-term Straw Returning on Soil Organic Carbon Fractions Composition in Rice-Wheat Rotation Ecosystem [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 166-175. |
[4] | Zhenjia HE, Wangtao FAN, Yichun DU, Qilong WANG. Effects of Water and Fertilizer Coupling on the Physical and Chemical Properties of Rice Soil and Yield Based on Soil Organic Reconstruction [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 176-185. |
[5] | Peng ZHONG, Lili MIAO, Jie LIU, Jianli WANG, Haiyan LU, Hongjiu YU, Nan ZHANG. Effect of Different Planting Densities and Patterns on Population Structure and Yield of Cyperusesculentus [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 186-196. |
[6] | Yunping DONG, Yuzhou LONG, Xingjun LIN, Lizhen MO, Huakang ZHU, Qingyun ZHAO, Yan SUN. Effect of Different Fertilizer Applications on Yield, Quality and Economic Benefit of CoffeaArabica L. [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(3): 197-203. |
[7] | Xin XU, Zhaowu MA, Shuping XIONG, Xinming MA, Tao CHENG, Haiyang LI, Jinpeng ZHAO. Wheat Yield Forecast in Henan Province Based on Climate Year Type [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 136-144. |
[8] | Baoshi LI, Wenke LIU, Qi WANG, Mingjie SHAO. Effect of Soil-ridged Substrate-embedded Cultivation on Root Zone Temperature, Growth and Yield of Cucumber in Chinese Solar Greenhouse in Summer [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 177-183. |
[9] | Xuan ZHOU, Pinling YANG, Jianwei PENG, Huiqing CHAI, Xuemei ZHONG, Xingrong KANG, Junyou LONG, Huiru ZHANG. Effects of Function Microbial Compound Fertilizer on Yield, Quality and Economic Benefit of Head Cabbage [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 184-192. |
[10] | Changjie CHEN, Lin MA, Yuhuan MIAO, Lanping GUO, Dahui LIU. Effects of Potassium Application on Growth, Yield and Quality of Artemisia argyi [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 201-209. |
[11] | Yuancheng ZHOU, Yongli CAO, Zhen WANG, Zhirong JIA, Yong YAO, Aiping CHEN. Screening and Evaluation of Drought Resistance Indexes in Different Barley Varieties [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(2): 86-92. |
[12] | Jian WANG, Ailing XU, Xiaodong WEI, Jilong XI, Na YANG, Ke WANG, Tianyuan XI, Jiancheng ZHANG. Risk Assessment of Spring Freezing Injury of Wheat at Different Sowing Dates in Yuncheng Basin [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(1): 137-147. |
[13] | Zhidan WANG, Jili LIU, Na WU. Effects of Fenlong Tillage on Photosynthetic Physiological Characteristics and Yield of Sweet Sorghum [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(1): 148-156. |
[14] | Xing LIU, Jitao WANG, Zhijun HU, Yan LIU, Xiaoguo MU, Haijun ZHANG, Dalin ZHANG, Lei AN, Lin YE. Effects of Planting Density and Feeding Frequency on Growth and Quality of Crucian Carp under Aquaponics System [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2022, 24(1): 192-201. |
[15] | HUANG Yulan§, LONG Shengfeng§, YE Xingzhi, LI Yanying, SHEN Zhangyou, ZHOU Jia, ZHOU Lingzhi, LAO Chengying, WEI Benhui. Study on the Agronomic Characters, Yield and Quality of Cassava in Enshi of Hubei Province [J]. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 2021, 23(9): 46-55. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||